So I just had to reset my password, and had a spot of trouble that stumped me for a couple minutes. In the recovery e-mail, the link to the password-changing page included the word "Then" from the sentence following it -- so it looked like "http://www.telltalegames.com/mail//mytelltale/passwordreset/57bThen just follow the instructions!" When it was converted into a hyperlink (not sure if that was GMail or on your side) it linked the entire thing (all the way through "Then"). When my browser opened this link, it was redirected to a normal log-in prompt (Please input username/password... a little tricky when your intent is to recover said password.) The end result was requesting a reset again, which didn't change a thing. It was then that I noticed the problem, removed the extraneous "Then" from the URL, and was able to successfully change my password.
I don't think I'll ever be having this problem again, but other users looking to recover their credentials may find it puzzling, so you guys may want to look into it. Otherwise, keep up the great work!