just started my first playthrough yesterday and reached the diner for the first time, just after talking with the sheriff in front of the eraser factory.
So now I am inside the diner and cant find him anywhere. I talked with everyone inside and did all puzzles available in there. Its also impossible to leave the diner again, because "I should talk to the sheriff first".
So did I just screw the game up somehow or am I just missing something? :confused: