Whenever I've been given the option to I've always stated the honest truth such as not being the little girl's dad. However Hersal called me her dad despite me telling Shawn I wasn't. Glenn did this too as well when he first called me on a walkie talkie. This to me doesn't make sense at all plot wise. It's like the game is assuming I am follow a linear path of choices. disregarding the ones I've been making.
Also another thing is when you get to the second town, the drug store. Kenny takes charge as group leader when they already had two group leaders. Before that nearly everyone was fighting with each other. How does it make sense that Kenny a brand new guy who they never seen can just order them around like that?
A minor issue I had was at Hershal's farm during shawn's tractor accident. At the end of it your given the option to blame Yourself, Nobody or Kenny. When it's clear that Duck, ducky, whatever the boy's name is at fault. He drove the tractor on accident and pinned Shawn down to the ground.
Does Telltale writers really think you shouldn't be able to blame the boy? Even if it was clearly just a accident? :confused: