I've played through the part of Episode 1 at Hershel's barn, and every time I play through, Hershel calls Lee out for being a liar. I'm trying to be honest with him, and I mention I was in the car with a police officer, and give my name during the first conversation, I'd already told Shawn I was Just Some Guy, and during the second conversation all the answers I pick, are to the best of my knowledge, honest (Was already heading out of Atlanta, Parents in Macon, etc). I guess I'm just asking if there are a specific set of responses you need to give Hershel to be 'honest', or is silence needed at some point, or what?
All that being said, I have finished the game a couple times now, and I'm dying for episode 2 already. Very, very well done.