User Avatar Image

Would you leave Lilly if she had killed Ben?

posted by Red Panda on - last edited - Viewed by 4.4K users

If, instead of Carley or Doug, Ben was killed would you leave Lilly by the road or taker her with you?

189 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • I'd have left her. Hated Ben and I suspected him also, but Lily was clearly unstable and I definitely wouldn't have wanted her anywhere near the group.

  • @Inferuz said: So many leaved her behind? I really liked her, he got allot of weight on her shoulders and she pushed trough it, her dad's fucking head was crushed in front of her, and she still saved me, two times against the two brothers.

    She was a crack shot like Carley, she was a huge asset to the team. I hate that she had to run with the r/v, she was like Andrea+Michonne+Abraham = Lilly.

    Well, i just hope i found her alive in upcoming episodes.

    Lee chopped the head of his undead brother, Kenny watched his wife commit suicide and then shot and killed his own son, yet neither of them let that destroy their minds to the point where they murder someone like Lilly did.

    I think most people left her behind for fear of her killing someone else.

  • Andrea+Michonne+Abraham = Lilly.

    Your comparing Andrea, Michonne & Abraham who'd go out of their way to help people, to Lilly, a selfish lazy crazy bitch that would leave a little girl to die?!?!
    Think of the shit that those three went through and ask if Lilly would do the same.

    Andrea single-handedly fought off the Governor with a gun shot wound, punched Spencer for suggesting to abandon the residents of Alexandria and was angry with Rick for giving up on the people of Alexandria.

    Michonne saved Otis by fighting off Zombies with a Samurai sword, helps the group on many occasions and even assisted Rick & Glenn to the helicopter site, was willing to get tortured a lot just so the Governor wouldn't know the location of the people she just met.

    Abraham helps out Rick's group the moment he meets them, agrees to go on suicide runs which leads him to take on a herd, he even saved Holly.

    Lilly is the woman that does nothing, was willing to let people die whether they were her own group members or not, kills an innocent person when their back is turned, this is the person that can't even go on supply runs let alone do the shit that Andrea, Michonne & Abraham did, she even ratted out Lee.

  • Leave her on the side of the road. Not because she killed Ben, he's alright and all but it's just I hate her and jump at the chance of kicking her out. She murdered someone! Sure you can argue that it's partially my fault since I help kill her dad, causing her to whacko. But still murder she murder a member of our group. She was dangerous and unstable, she could end up hurting or killing someone else, like Clem.

  • @IceRyder said: Your comparing Andrea, Michonne & Abraham who'd go out of their way to help people, to Lilly, a selfish lazy crazy bitch that would leave a little girl to die?!?!
    Think of the shit that those three went through and ask if Lilly would do the same.

    Andrea single-handedly fought off the Governor with a gun shot wound, punched Spencer for suggesting to abandon the residents of Alexandria and was angry with Rick for giving up on the people of Alexandria.

    Michonne saved Otis by fighting off Zombies with a Samurai sword, helps the group on many occasions and even assisted Rick & Glenn to the helicopter site, was willing to get tortured a lot just so the Governor wouldn't know the location of the people she just met.

    Abraham helps out Rick's group the moment he meets them, agrees to go on suicide runs which leads him to take on a herd, he even saved Holly.

    Lilly is the woman that does nothing, was willing to let people die whether they were her own group members or not, kills an innocent person when their back is turned, this is the person that can't even go on supply runs let alone do the shit that Andrea, Michonne & Abraham did, she even ratted out Lee.


    I was talking about skillz to pay the bills. And we just met Lilly, remember Vegeta? He was bad at first, he did allot of stupid shit yet he is one of the best characters of all time of anything and most loved.

    I don't remember Tyreese well but he did stupid shit too.

    Abraham and Michonne where badass from the beginning.. or at least the first time we(readers) met them, Andrea got to "grew up" and adapt to the new world. She wanted to quit like a coward, thankfully Dale did sumting.

  • @Mornai said: Lee chopped the head of his undead brother, Kenny watched his wife commit suicide and then shot and killed his own son, yet neither of them let that destroy their minds to the point where they murder someone like Lilly did.

    I think most people left her behind for fear of her killing someone else.


    Lilly was unestable already. There is no explanation that justifies what she did because it was stupid, i would like to execute Ben for his actions, that is what Rick or Andrea would have done.

    He got away with it, two innocents die because of it, Katjaa's death was her choice not Ben's fault. Of course Ben stupidity was like cocking the gun.

  • To Inferuz

    I was talking about skillz to pay the bills. And we just met Lilly, remember Vegeta? He was bad at first, he did allot of stupid shit yet he is one of the best characters of all time of anything and most loved.

    In 3 Episodes, she showed no skills. Did nothing in the first episode. Did mostly nothing in the second episode(depending on the choices you make) but then again, she couldn't get a head shot on Andy with a sniper rifle and as someone suggested, she couldn't take out a zombified Mr Parker/Travis when it attacked Lee and she had the perfect sight to take him out.

    Third episode, OK I'll give her the fact she took out a bandit and I'll say "a" bandit because with the rifle she had, she only managed to kill one while Lee & Carley(depending) had to deal with the rest. But she did it in a reckless way that could've put members of her group in danger and it could've been avoided if she was on watch instead of telling a shit for brains kid to do it while she was hiding in doors.

    But the fact remains she did mostly nothing in 3 episodes, Carley with her dead-eye is a better shot than her, she assists you at times & did more for the group than Lilly who mostly sits around doing nothing.

    Notice how Lilly has not killed one zombie in the 3 episodes she was in, her kill count is 1 bandit & 1 innocent person in the back. Even Clementine, Doug & Ben killed Zombies, if a child, a nerd and an idiot can do it, how useful is she really especially as a leader?

    And this is The Walking Dead not Dragon Ball Z.

    I don't remember Tyreese well but he did stupid shit too.

    Even after his daughter's death, Tyreese still did things to help the group. He didn't snap at anyone or kill anyone for no reason. He didn't sit his ass around doing nothing.

    Abraham and Michonne where badass from the beginning.. or at least the first time we(readers) met them, Andrea got to "grew up" and adapt to the new world. She wanted to quit like a coward, thankfully Dale did sumting.

    Like Tyreese. Andrea lost her only family yet still contemplated more in the safety of the group. She didn't sit around doing nothing and rely on others to take care of her and constantly snap at people and she certainly didn't murder anyone for no reason. She didn't cause problems for others. Abraham & Michonne were bad-asses when you meet them but they do tell you their story and frankly, they lost more family members than Lilly has yet they still keep it together and like Tyreese & Andrea, they actually do things to keep people safe.

    i would like to execute Ben for his actions, that is what Rick or Andrea would have done.

    No they wouldn't. They didn't kill Patricia when she helped the two prisoners to get weapons to kick the group out of the prison. They didn't kill Nicholas when he plotted to have them thrown out and to kill Rick. I'm sure they'll spare Ben knowing that he didn't mean any harm to others as he thinks he was helping out the group, which he did, kept the bandits at Bay to give Kenny more time on the RV, only mistake he made was not telling the group about it.

    He got away with it, two innocents die because of it, Katjaa's death was her choice not Ben's fault. Of course Ben stupidity was like cocking the gun.

    OK, if the math is done right. He only got one person killed, Duck. You say Katjaa's death was her choice so that counts her out. And he can't take all the blame for Lilly going gun crazy on Doug/Carley. He may have played the part but he didn't hypnotize Lilly into murdering her group members.

  • @IceRyder said: To Inferuz

    Even Clementine, Doug & Ben killed Zombies, if a child, a nerd and an idiot can do it, how useful is she really especially as a leader?

    Just putting it out there, Ben has never been seen killing a walker until the stand off scene in EP5, and even then it's not clear if one of those that was shot was from him.

  • @Yertos said: Just putting it out there, Ben has never been seen killing a walker until the stand off scene in EP5, and even then it's not clear if one of those that was shot was from him.

    Well, he's seen shooting walkers with a rifle in the teaser for episode 2, but i suppose that doesn't count.

Add Comment