Who did not take the food from the car? That was a key element to episode 5 and I made three save files where each one took the food and I don't plan on going that far back only for one scene.
If you did not pick up the food, tell me what the radio guy spoke to you about.
By picking up the food, he says that food and stuff in the car was his. He also says that was the reason he kidnapped Clementine. So what did he say as his reason if you didn't pick it up?