User Avatar Image

Twdsi vs twdttg

posted by amigosolitario on - last edited - Viewed by 374 users

the walking dead survival instinct or the walking dead telltalegames

34 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • TTG game by far. The Daryl game is.. Bad. REALLY BAAAAAD!

  • I agree with Riadon [edit] and CarScar. lol

    In fairness, though, I've only seen trailers and minor game play when it comes to Survival Instinct, but it just doesn't seem like it'd be up my alley. Not to mention that you're comparing an RPG and FPS. I think, because of the forum you're posting it on, you're going to hear predominantly that people prefer TTG's The Walking Dead Game.

    Personally, I do like FPS, but I prefer RPGs. And considering I prefer the comics to the show, I feel it's safe to assume I'd prefer the storyline of TTG's TWD to Activision's. However, when it inevitably goes on sale for super-cheap, I'll probably pick up a copy and give it a try hehe.

  • I bought the walking dead survival instinct and ended up returning it (selling) the very next day and got TOMB RAIDER! Very happy I did, cause Tomb Raider is pretty amazing, and im not a fan of the previous games.

    The Walking dead throws you in the story right away, with avg graphics and boring missions. Nothing really changes, and seems like a half attempt at making a game. I found it boring, repetitive, and half assed at an attempt of the show. AVOID if you can, but I can understand people curious to see it. I would just wait on The Walking Dead (Telltale) to come out with a new episode.

  • Let's see....

    ....EXTREMELY BUGGY point and click game with a FANTASTIC STORY.

    vs

    ....VERY ROUGH first person TWD version of THE LAST STAND 2.

    I'd say they're equal.

  • @DreadMagus said: Let's see....

    ....EXTREMELY BUGGY point and click game with a FANTASTIC STORY.

    vs

    ....VERY ROUGH first person TWD version of THE LAST STAND 2.

    I'd say they're equal.



    The only major glitch that's actually common is the savegame one, and while that is very serious it doesn't constitute "extremely" buggy. A better example of extremely buggy would be Sonic 06, or if it counts, big rigs.

    Also, i would normally expect full retail games to be far superior to flash games(even though i loved the Last Stand games).

  • @Mornai said: A better example of extremely buggy would be Sonic 06, or if it counts, big rigs.


    You mean to say that big rigs constitutes as a game :eek:?
    Jokes aside, I haven't even played Survival Instinct and TWD by Telltale is better. I might be a little biased however, considering that TWD by Telltale is my favorite game of all time.

  • @Mornai said: The only major glitch that's actually common is the savegame one, and while that is very serious it doesn't constitute "extremely" buggy. A better example of extremely buggy would be Sonic 06, or if it counts, big rigs.

    Also, i would normally expect full retail games to be far superior to flash games(even though i loved the Last Stand games).



    I've got a bug that makes it impossible to save on any slot but slot 3.

    I call that extremely buggy.

  • I gave survival instinct a 1 overall, whereas I have TWD game a 10 of 10. I experienced buggy gameplay, but the game still blew my mind. Check out the reviews of SI, and you'll understand why you SHOULD NOT buy it!!!! The game sucks so bad, and I went through the entire game(didnt buy it though :P) still, it makes telltale's bugs look super minor in comparison. There were invisible walls the walkers couldn't get through xD that and barriers you as the main couldn't get through(especially small fences).

    I am a serious walking dead fan, and this game made me want to throw up. If you bought it already, try it yourself. If you like it, beat it, and then immediately sell it, unless you want to play it again, at which point you should slam your head against the nearest wall. If you haven't bought it yet, look it up. Just don't go buy it, it's terrible, and I'd hate to see people loss out $50.

Add Comment