User Avatar Image

If Lilly would kill Clem would you still forgive her ?

posted by master psychic on - last edited - Viewed by 2.2K users

I noticed that Lilly fans always forgive her for many things like :
1 Letting people die outside the pharmacy
2 Killing Carley/Doug
3 Stealing the RV
I don' want to start a flame war with Lilly fans i understand their reason for liking her but i don't like how they always forgive her , pity her and saying that she suffered more than Lee , Clementine and Kenny etc , and they always make both Kenny and Carley look like the bad guys .
With Kenny i understand that he did horrible things but in the end he atoned for his sins and Lilly fans criticize him for that too
With Carley Lilly fans hate her because Carley called her the B word , well she did that because Lilly was accusing her of being a traitor and she wasn't going to calm down .
So here's the scenario : Lilly and Clem are in season 2 and they meet , Lilly wants to kill her because she is a reminder of her crime and her father's death so when Clem turns her back she tries to shoot her but the new protagonist stops her .
If Lilly would do this would you fans and Lilly fans still forgive her and make Clementine look like the bad guy by saying " Well Clem reminds her too much of Carley/Doug and Larry so she has the right to kill her " or stop treating her like a victim and acknowledge her crime .

243 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • Unlikely. While there might be some extreme Lilly fans who would still support her, i think most players would change their mind when a child's death is concerned, even if they don't like Clem.

    For example... if Lee turned around and straight up murdered Duck for no reason i would hate him(even though i dislike Duck).

  • Kind of neutral on Lilly, but I don't see her killing a kid (unless it's similar to duck situation, maybe). Actually, I don't see her being a murderer setting out to kill people. Yeah she kills Carley/Doug , but, at least to me, she's like "Oh god, what have I just done?" afterwards

    Really, I didn't see them with anyone who would do that in their group this season.

  • If i couldnt forgive her for killing Carley, what makes you think i can forgive her for killing Clem? :/

  • The first thing on my mind when she shot Carley/Doug was to outright kill her... so yea.
    If someone kills a person straight up like that then they have no business around me, also her dad who tried to kill you. So if she comes back i'm hitting the GTFO or kill her button.

    Overall i did not agree with Lilly at all except in the meat locker, Kenny panicked and made a rushed decision which was stupid.

  • @Virtumonde said: The first thing on my mind when she shot Carley/Doug was to outright kill her... so yea.
    If someone kills a person straight up like that then they have no business around me, also her dad who tried to kill you. So if she comes back i'm hitting the GTFO or kill her button.

    Overall i did not agree with Lilly at all except in the meat locker, Kenny panicked and made a rushed decision which was stupid.

    I agree to the first, though about Kenny:
    It is very debatable, because if Larry had turned, the group would have been fucked, considering how little time it took travis/Mr.Parker to turn that was an actual threat to the group. Maybe it was a rushed decision, but helping Lilly was irresponsible in my opinion, I mean Clem was in the room, and if Larry had turned, well then...

  • @ZeroShoot said: I agree to the first, though about Kenny:
    It is very debatable, because if Larry had turned, the group would have been fucked, considering how little time it took travis/Mr.Parker to turn that was an actual threat to the group. Maybe it was a rushed decision, but helping Lilly was irresponsible in my opinion, I mean Clem was in the room, and if Larry had turned, well then...

    I agree the decision is debatable. Kenny wasn't wrong when he said we should kill him... at first i agreed, but damn he isn't gonna turn in 30 seconds... if you help and perform CPR on Larry he starts breathing but Kenny smashes his face. Therefor i call a rushed decision on Kenny, but that's my opinion.

  • Lilly will not do that because she is one of people who took care of her & also play with her like you can see at the end from Episode 2.

  • I don't like Lilly at all, but she's not evil. She's just a bitch. She'd never hurt a child (knowingly), even if it would benefit her in some way to do so. I didn't forgive her for killing Carley and left her behind, so I'm sure that gives you my answer in the unlikely event of Clem ever being harmed by Lilly's hand.

Add Comment