Am i the only who thinks that Lilly should be punished for her crimes if she appears in season 2 ? Yeah i know we are going get a new protagonist and he won't know Lilly but if she and Clem appear , i can imagine Clem telling the protagonist about Lilly and then the protagonist captures her to be sure that she won't escape , and then he and the new group decide what are they going to do with her because she might kill one of them and you have to decide kill her or spare her but i would choose to spare her but not before beating the shit out of her because even if you spare her she should atleast get a beating like Kenny if you decide to fight him on the train .
This is a theory though but to be honest if Lilly appears in season 2 i hope we get an option to punish her like either killing her , sparing her or beating her .
I'm sorry Lilly fans but just because you all like her it doesn't mean she can run away from her horrible crimes and pretend it never happened , Kenny and Ben did many horrible things but they regret those actions while Lilly din't show any regrets about killing Doug/Carley and stealing the RV . Kenny in the end sacrificed himself so then he can atone for his sins , Ben tried to redeem himself by saving Clementine if you convince him to go with you while Lilly never apologised about her actions and she actually abandons the two people she cares about aka Lee ( only if you help her with her dad ) and Clementine if you choose to pick her up . She may of had good intentions for the group but in the end '' The road to Hell is paved with good intentions " and " No good deed goes unpunished " Lilly fits those phrases .
So do you guys think that if Lilly appears in season 2 she should get punished ?