User Avatar Image

Lilly should be punished for her crimes

posted by master psychic on - last edited - Viewed by 1.1K users

Am i the only who thinks that Lilly should be punished for her crimes if she appears in season 2 ? Yeah i know we are going get a new protagonist and he won't know Lilly but if she and Clem appear , i can imagine Clem telling the protagonist about Lilly and then the protagonist captures her to be sure that she won't escape , and then he and the new group decide what are they going to do with her because she might kill one of them and you have to decide kill her or spare her but i would choose to spare her but not before beating the shit out of her because even if you spare her she should atleast get a beating like Kenny if you decide to fight him on the train .
This is a theory though but to be honest if Lilly appears in season 2 i hope we get an option to punish her like either killing her , sparing her or beating her .
I'm sorry Lilly fans but just because you all like her it doesn't mean she can run away from her horrible crimes and pretend it never happened , Kenny and Ben did many horrible things but they regret those actions while Lilly din't show any regrets about killing Doug/Carley and stealing the RV . Kenny in the end sacrificed himself so then he can atone for his sins , Ben tried to redeem himself by saving Clementine if you convince him to go with you while Lilly never apologised about her actions and she actually abandons the two people she cares about aka Lee ( only if you help her with her dad ) and Clementine if you choose to pick her up . She may of had good intentions for the group but in the end '' The road to Hell is paved with good intentions " and " No good deed goes unpunished " Lilly fits those phrases .
So do you guys think that if Lilly appears in season 2 she should get punished ?

81 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • I think being abandoned on the side of the road with nothing to protect herself with is punishment enough. (Unless she steps out of line again)

  • No apology needed. I'm a Lilly fan and I can see your point. I blamed Kenny for everything much in the same way you blame Lilly. But at least I got the satisfaction of telling Kenny to go fuck himself and then watch him die a gruesome and pointless death.

    You didn't get this kind of closure for a character you disliked. She'll probably be in season 2 but what could suck is that you will have to interact with her for a few episodes before the opportunity to avenge Carley presents itself.

    Hang in there. It's worth the wait :D.

  • @Kiel555 said: No apology needed. I'm a Lilly fan and I can see your point. I blamed Kenny for everything much in the same way you blame Lilly. But at least I got the satisfaction of telling Kenny to go fuck himself and then watch him die a gruesome and pointless death.

    You didn't get this kind of closure for a character you disliked. She'll probably be in season 2 but what could suck is that you will have to interact with her for a few episodes before the opportunity to avenge Carley presents itself.

    Hang in there. It's worth the wait :D.

    Thanks for the advice :D , but if she appears in season 2 i can imagine her being the same like in season 1 but then there is similar scenario in episode 3 or 4 of season 2 where there is a new asshole who is a bit like Lilly and Larry combined and accuses 2 people from the new group of being liabilities and Lilly sees the asshole getting his gun and she imagines the 2 people Carley and Ben or Doug and Ben if you save him and then she tells Clem to take care of herself and fight to the end and then she gets in the way and the asshole shoots her instead of those 2 people which would be a good way for her to redeem herself for Carley/Doug and for Clem .

  • Too much attantion for Lilly. Leave her alone!

  • @master psychic said: Am i the only who thinks that Lilly should be punished for her crimes if she appears in season 2 ? Yeah i know we are going get a new protagonist and he won't know Lilly but if she and Clem appear , i can imagine Clem telling the protagonist about Lilly and then the protagonist captures her to be sure that she won't escape , and then he and the new group decide what are they going to do with her because she might kill one of them and you have to decide kill her or spare her but i would choose to spare her but not before beating the shit out of her because even if you spare her she should atleast get a beating like Kenny if you decide to fight him on the train .
    This is a theory though but to be honest if Lilly appears in season 2 i hope we get an option to punish her like either killing her , sparing her or beating her .
    I'm sorry Lilly fans but just because you all like her it doesn't mean she can run away from her horrible crimes and pretend it never happened , Kenny and Ben did many horrible things but they regret those actions while Lilly din't show any regrets about killing Doug/Carley and stealing the RV . Kenny in the end sacrificed himself so then he can atone for his sins , Ben tried to redeem himself by saving Clementine if you convince him to go with you while Lilly never apologised about her actions and she actually abandons the two people she cares about aka Lee ( only if you help her with her dad ) and Clementine if you choose to pick her up . She may of had good intentions for the group but in the end '' The road to Hell is paved with good intentions " and " No good deed goes unpunished " Lilly fits those phrases .
    So do you guys think that if Lilly appears in season 2 she should get punished ?

    lol. Just imagine a situation, you're not familiar with this girl (you're a new protagonist), you who once said that she did terrible thing, but she did nothing wrong to you Now she's got a weapon, she has a lot of experience for survival, she really knows how to kill a zombie, and is the main character was going to kill her just because of the fact that he had heard that she had killed an innocent man?
    It's just not reasonable, why deprive your team of experienced military unit, who is a Lilly?
    Oh... of course Clem can say: "She's bad, she killed poor Carley... we need to leave her in here, by walkers! *cute eyes* "
    And many will do it, because blindly believe Clem, and wants a dumb useless revenge. But I personally would be in this situation would say: " Please, shut fuck up, my dear" .
    I belive that Lilly can be really helpfull for new main hero, she's goddamn ex military, who can kill, and this skill is the most needed for survival in the conditions of zombie apocalypse.
    There are not too much people who are still not walkers to kill them in vain, for the revenge. I will never forgive her what she did with Carley/Doug, but as like I said I can't wasting experienced people in vain. Also she's a woman! I hope you understand that human population can't be regenerated without womans!
    But if you don't need additional fighter, additional chance to survive, then go on, shoot her.

  • I'd say punishing her depends on what Lee did after she killed Carley/Doug. If Lee abandoned her on the side of the road (like I did) hen I'd say that she was already punished by having to fend for herself against the walkers and whatever crazies might have been out there. I'd still do something if she even tried to pull something like that again, but as it s, she's been punished enough (for now) in my game.

    I'd say she should get a beating, like you said, or some such if the player decided to let her back on. Not only does she kill a group member, but instead of taking her chance to make things right, she takes the group's only mode (known to her, at that time) of transportation and leaves three adults, two children, and an idiot to starve or be killed by walkers, and gets away with it! After she had already murdered one of them because of a mistake or simply because she was called a nasty name.

    Just because I won't punish her, barring any future stuff she does, in my game doesn't mean I forgive her. If she wants her redemption, she's gonna have to earn it!

  • I'd also have to question the idea Ben and Kenny redeemed themselves or atoned. They might have started on that route days or weeks after their respective crimes, but they had a long way to go; Kenny's potential friendly bodycount is the highest out of everyone's and starts at the very first episode when he leaves Shawn to die. If you help Lilly with Larry, he leaves Lee to die atleast twice in the space of about a week (in situations where he has a duty to help), etc. Hell, the man's own wife literally couldn't stand living with what he had become once Duck was gone.

    Ben's failures in dealing with the bandits shouldn't require explanation.

    Only real difference is that Lilly killed somebody we happened to like; had she just killed Ben, I doubt people would care half as much.

  • ^I still would have, just because I didn't like Lilly after episode 2.

  • To be fair she didn't try to kill Doug...
    If Doug wasn't such a nice guy, Ben would have died...
    But then again if Doug wasn't the nice guy who would he be?

  • What she did was totally out of line I imagine she will be a little crazy like that lady that was watching over Clem
    So put it this way if we do see her again... I'll be keeping a very close eye on her and I'll have very little tolerance for her

Add Comment