I purchased this game solely to get the unlockables for Borderlands 2. I have completed all 5 bounties. You can check my achievements, GT: Johnny Nitro. I also have a Shift account, as is evidenced by my 44 pending Golden keys.
When I log into BL2, I only have 3 messages from Shift about Poker Night, one for Zero, one for Gaige, and one for Maya. Axton and Salvador, though I have their bounty items, and have pushed X to download in Poker Night 2, don't show up in the shift section.
Even worse, of the 3/5 that DO show up, only Maya's skin is actually present. Gaige and Zero's skins both don't show up when at a customization station.
At this point, I'm feeling pretty ripped off. Is there some way to get those items?