User Avatar Image

How would your perception of Luke change if...

posted by FlamingOblivion on - last edited - Viewed by 1.9K users

I'm going to give you two scenarios and I want you to post how you would feel about Luke in each individual scenario. These scenarios are just hypothetical and not to be taken seriously.

Scenario #1: Luke tries to convince Kenny that they should fall back and live to fight another day. Kenny considers this whining and tells Luke to "take a hike." Left with no other choice and unable to sway stubborn Kenny, Luke withdraws himself from the hostage situation in hopes of preventing any casualties. In episode 3, Luke will track Carver down to his community and formulate a plan to liberate the group. Luke will find the 400 days characters in Carver's camp. He will intentionally get himself caught by Carver so he can persuade the 400 days characters to turn against Carver (just like the cabin group) causing an uprising which is just the distraction that the group needs to set their prison break plan in motion.

Scenario #2: Luke is nagging Kenny that they should escape while they still can. Kenny refusing to leave his group behind, tells Luke to "take a hike." Luke with his keep moving on attitude takes Kenny's advice and runs away. Luke considers the capture of his group as a loss and it's probably best to move on. Luke continues to survive without looking back.

How would your opinion on Luke change between these two absolutely different scenarios.

40 Comments
  • Situation #1: I already like Luke as it is. If he does pull it off and show that he cares about us then I would think more highly of him.

    Situation #2: Did he just pull a Ben on us!?

  • 1: Luke your a great guy! 2: Nick! Shoot this guy off a bridge!

  • Scenario 1: Shoot him. Make it quick and painless

    Scenario 2: I'll give him a head start and make him think he's getting away just so I can mow him down moments later in the most painful way possible.

  • I hate Luke, so.. Scenario 1 I think he would be actually pretty nice, so I might like em. Scenario 2 Hes a pissant!

    In all seriousness, I would hate em if he did the things in Scenario 2 and track em down and murder him! Scenario 1 EPIC DUDE!

  • Scenario #1: I seriously hope that happens, I want see more 400 Day's group. even more so now I seen Bonnie now a bad guy, I need convincing the other guys a good people.

    Scenario #2: I would feel betrayed, Sad not see any more of Clem-Luke brother and sister relationship. If this is indeed the case next time I see Luke I will fight him.

    • Scenario 1 - I wouldn't expect anything less and I would probably end up trusting and liking Luke even more.

    • Scenario 2 - Clem: "Im not an asshole" Luke: "you calling me an asshole?" yes Luke, I am.

  • 1: FUCK YEAH! LUKE!

    2: Come on, dude. Get some balls!

  • Here's what needs to happen! Everyone is at the camp, and Carver is interrogating everyone in the camp's cafeteria. All the other people in the camp are also in the room and having a good time. Suddenly, Luke kicks the cafeteria doors open, and steps inside, clad with a wide-brimmed cowboy hat, and a poncho. Everybody in the room is quiet and turns to look at him...

    I don't care what happens after or before. Gotta love westerns.

  • Scenario 1: He's reliable and proved to me that I can trust him from now on. c:

    Scenario 2: He better hope that he never crosses me again. >:c

  • Scenario #1 would not happen. Sorry to be a party pooper, but Carver is completely focused around social and psychological control. You think he would just allow Luke, a very charming and somewhat persuasive (in his own way) guy to just freely enter the camp and hang out with the other survivors? Carver is very psychologically intelligent, and if he really wanted to allow Luke into the camp with the others, he would break him first. I hope you all understand what I mean by "break him".

    But, let's suppose that Carver does allow him back into the group. Sure, Luke is a charmer, but do you honestly think that he would have the capability of convincing people to turn against a semi-tyrant who undoubtedly has armed guards and has his own heavy firepower? All it would take is one doubter and the entire thing would fall apart even if he somehow managed to convince them to turn on Carver.

    As for scenario 2...

    He would actually be smart to do this, assuming he has the survival skills necessary to live on your own in this kind of world. If he broke away from everyone he would no longer have to deal with the Carver threat and could focus on survival and possibly finding another group.

    If he left after Kenny told him to f*** off, I honestly wouldn't blame him, especially because I sat at the table with Kenny without any hesitation. Luke is a cool dude and all, but Kenny has been my homie since Season 1 and had my Lee's back through thick and thin.

    /my2cents

Add Comment