This discussion may contain spoilers!
Ok, I am going to do something a bit different this time and make the "did you try?" list a team endeavor. I will be replaying the game a few times this week, so I will update My list as I find new items... But I am also inviting anyone who has found something interesting to post it below and add to the list... So check this thread often. :)
In Tales of Monkey Island: Launch of the Screaming Narwhal: did you...
In the Teaser...
Look at the hold, door, and ships wheel for the previous monkey island throwbacks while on guybrush's ship?
Look at both the cannon on guybrush's ship, and the kegs of gunpowder on Elaine's ship?
Use a breath mint with the hold on Eliane's ship?
Use the breath mints with Elaine, the important monkey, and LeChuck while in Elaine's boat?
Use the unfinished sword with Elaine, LeChuck, and the monkey while on Elaine's boat?
Use the monkey coffin with the important monkey?
Look at the empty barrel, monkey coffin, spilled grog, trimmed plant, and cutlass after enchanting the cutlass?
Act One (Acts of Piracy)
Repeatedly look at the broken rowboat?
Try giving a flower to D'oro, the voodoo lady, and Winslow on the Norwall
Examine the well, alter, and calender in the jungle?
Examine the weather vane, and printing press over the keelhauler gazette?
examine the scientific instrument on De Singes balcony
Look at the ancient columns by the dock twice?
Use the stolen Pink Pajama Pierre doll with D'Oro the Explorer?
Look at the socks again after picking up the club card?
Letting a lit bomb go off in Guybrush's pants?
Show the flyer to every character? (Nipperkin, the glass blower, Winslow, D'oro, and the voodoo lady
Look at the club 41 carpet both before and after causing the barfight
Try to dunk something besides the doll in the ink vat?
Try to sacrifice a pirate doll on the alter?
Try to throw an unlit bomb at Winslow? (and look at the lit bomb in your inventory?)
Knock on the doctors door after completing each of the 3 acts of piracy?
Guess all the wrong passwords trying to get into the voodoo ladys shack before getting the map from Nipperkin?
Read ALL the book titles on the voodoo ladys shelf?
Pixel hunt the voodoo ladys shack and the shrunken heads, terrot cards, hand lotion, and examine crystal ball twice?
Check out all the changing item titles in the voodoo ladys shack after clicking on everything?
Act Two (The Pox Rolls In)
Try to leave the voodoo shack without taking the bottle?
Look at the shack again from the outside after you've met the Voodoo Lady?
Look at the pox in the sky? (twice?)
Try to christen the Narwhal with the unbreakable bottle?
Fire the unbreakable bottle from the Narwhal's cannon?
Try to open the unbreakable bottle with the grease fire?
Look at the keelhauler gazette headlines after the pox sets in?
Talk to MaGee before seeing the doctor, then ask the De Singe about MaGee?
Hit the "I" key to try and open your inventory while strapped to the chair?
Notable examines on the lab, look at the caged monkey twice, the microscope, the chemicals on the shelf, the books over the other shelf, the door twice, the balcony door, and the test tubes (but there are many others)
Zap the monkey while its on Guybrush's shoulder? (without the key on its tail)
Look at Jaque the monkey after each step of the lab puzzle?
Talk to the Voodoo Lady after escaping the lab, asking her about Grog and De Singe?
Try to give the pyrite parrot and weather vane back to the voodoo lady?
Show the bottle breaker to the voodoo lady?
Show the map to the voodoo lady after retrieving it from the bottle?
Talk to MaGee again after opening the bottle?
Show the flyer to MaGee?
Talk to the glassblower (twice) through his store door after smashing his unicorns with the cannon?
Break a you tube with the bottle breaker and ask the glassblower for another one?
Try to open the voodoo ladys diaroama with the bottle opener?
Try to break the voodoo ladys crystal ball with the bottle breaker?
Act Three (A fair wind)
Talk to MaGee and the voodoo lady after finding the wind temple
Use the the pyrite parrot with the ancient door before opening it?
Lure De Singe twice to the door twice before putting the parrot through the hole?
Repeatedly say "hey look..." to De Singe to hear all the king louis gags?
Try to use the weather vane on De Singe in the idol?
Act Four (The Narwhal sets sail)
Look at the spilled tar (twice) and at the mainmast after breaking the tar barrel?
Repeatedly try moving when stuck in the tar?
... To Be Continued
(And I don't think I need to tell you all to click everything until the dialogue repeats itself, to examine your items frequently (epically after combining/using them with other objects), and to use every inventory item with at least one random (out of inventory) item and character.)
P.S. if you have any noteworthy hidden gags or dialogue that you found, feel free to post how to trigger them here.
A VERY special thanks to Secret Fawful, Mad Mary, Shale, Planeforger, meander, Higure, Largo LaGrande, EdWont, JanT, Fausk, Anieartalia, der_ketzer, jeditribble, walshy, prizna, Bur, a3HeadedMonkey, Magwill, jeditribble, octochan, TofuHead, hplikelike, Wolfwood, Zomantic, and Randulf for their help with the contents of this list.