Ok, I finished the game, but I think I just completed this puzzle based on pure luck. So, how does this work? I kept getting hints from Sam like "I'd give the pharaoh an aglet, but he had them all destroyed", which led me to think I had to turn Max into an aglet, but it seemed more likely to be the toaster. All I remember was walking around all over the place and then going back to Sal, choosing the toaster, and it being right, but several times before that, he wouldn't take it because everyone else was giving him toasters. So what do I do?