The atmosphere is FANTASTIC.
A pure throwback to early Twin Peaks-ian goodness that I immensely enjoyed along with the unique art style.
The gameplay however was plain atrocious. The puzzles were cute at first but quickly became repetitive and a retro-geeklords' wet dream.
It's a waste to use such a beautiful and unique artistic vision to cater to 15 or maybe 20 30yr olds-in-their-parents'-basements.
I say make it a traditional Telltale adventure game and I'm sold.
As it is, I'll be sticking to Sammun Mak.