I signed up to say this.
I just bought Puzzle Agent because it came in a bundle on Steam really cheap. I had seen the game before but it never caught my attention. Worst mistake ever.
I absolutely love this game. As soon as I started it I didn't want to stop until it was finished (and I would've gotten away with it too if it wasn't for appointments!). Amazing visuals, story, voiceovers, music, everything. The atmosphere was perfect, and the comedy was always in the right places.
So, because of this game, I'm definitely going to look into Telltale's other games. Which makes me ask, for someone like me, who's first Telltale game is Puzzle Agent, what would you suggest next?
Also, is there going to be a sequel to Puzzle Agent? There really needs to be. While I did enjoy the game, the ending left me wanting so much more.