User Avatar Image

Most Suprising Events From EP3?

posted by SouthWardRB on - last edited - Viewed by 747 users

This episode was amazing if you don't care about the characters, but the worst one yet if you do. For me:

1. Katjaa and Duck dying, I wasn't expecting duck to be bit, I expected if he were to die he would be eaten. Katjaa committing scuicide.:eek:

2. Carley dying. I knew she was going die eventually, since it was eitherDoug or Carley, it would require to much effort by TTG to develope both characters. But the way she died so abruptly, and after I thought a Lee+Carley thin would happen, especially after carley kissed lee.

So many people fought Kenny. Wtf

29 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • @SouthWardRB said: This episode was amazing if you don't care about the characters, but the worst one yet if you do. For me:

    1. Katjaa and Duck dying, I wasn't expecting duck to be bit, I expected if he were to die he would be eaten. Katjaa committing scuicide.:eek:

    2. Carley dying. I knew she was going die eventually, since it was eitherDoug or Carley, it would require to much effort by TTG to develope both characters. But the way she died so abruptly, and after I thought a Lee+Carley thin would happen, especially after carley kissed lee.

    So many people fought Kenny. Wtf

    1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.

    2. Carly's death was...well, really just felt like a cheap way of getting rid of a character to open things up for the new characters. Normally in Kirkman's graphic novel when a well established, and liked, character dies it feels senseless, but it does add to the grim dramatic narrative. Carly's death just felt like a cop out.

    Really believe it was a failing on TT's part that they felt unable/unwilling to continue to develop either Carly or Doug. I understand that the game isn't a Triple-A title with a Mass Effect 3 like budget, but it really did just feel like a lazy, empty kill. This is, of course, just my opinion.

    As for Kenny, no one can say he did not have it coming from the start. Really a tragic character.

  • @ComixFan said: 1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.

    2. Carly's death was...well, really just felt like a cheap way of getting rid of a character to open things up for the new characters. Normally in Kirkman's graphic novel when a well established, and liked, character dies it feels senseless, but it does add to the grim dramatic narrative. Carly's death just felt like a cop out.

    Really believe it was a failing on TT's part that they felt unable/unwilling to continue to develop either Carly or Doug. I understand that the game isn't a Triple-A title with a Mass Effect 3 like budget, but it really did just feel like a lazy, empty kill. This is, of course, just my opinion.

    As for Kenny, no one can say he did not have it coming from the start. Really a tragic character.

    I felt incredibly sorry for Kenny by the time the episode was over. Honestly, I'll give TT credit for that. I hated Kenny after the end of E2, but having to shoot Duck turned it around.

  • @ComixFan said: 1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made. Won't spoil it, but it can be done and avoided. So point one is not something that *has* to happen.

    2. Carly's death was...well, really just felt like a cheap way of getting rid of a character to open things up for the new characters. Normally in Kirkman's graphic novel when a well established, and liked, character dies it feels senseless, but it does add to the grim dramatic narrative. Carly's death just felt like a cop out.

    Really believe it was a failing on TT's part that they felt unable/unwilling to continue to develop either Carly or Doug. I understand that the game isn't a Triple-A title with a Mass Effect 3 like budget, but it really did just feel like a lazy, empty kill. This is, of course, just my opinion.

    As for Kenny, no one can say he did not have it coming from the start. Really a tragic character.

    Would you mind spoiling 1.? I'm interested to know what i'd have to do differently.

  • @SadClown said: At least now we have some sort of idea of how Lilly ended up in the comics.

    this is not the same lilly

  • I literally signed up just now so I could ask if we could save Katjaa/duck. Can someone please PM me or just explain it in here how I can save them?

    I would be extremely appreciative.

  • @Exzander said: I literally signed up just now so I could ask if we could save Katjaa/duck. Can someone please PM me or just explain it in here how I can save them?

    I would be extremely appreciative.

    I would also like to know how too! Please inform :confused:

  • @canadianzombie said: I would also like to know how too! Please inform :confused:

    Wait wait wait... you can save them?
    HOW?:confused::confused::confused:

  • @ComixFan said: 1. Katjaa's suicide and Duck being put down from the Zombie bite can be avoided depending choices made.


    Proof or I call BS.

  • @PuhChewyChomp said: Proof or I call BS.

    It is BS his even asking in another thread if its possible lol

    Maybe a fanboy giving telltale more credit then they deserve>???

  • Damn it...that damn,damn curiosity... its over now.I just...had to read...curiosity... :(

Add Comment