User Avatar Image

Bring ***** Back! ( or maybe ***** )

posted by ZombieBlaster on - last edited - Viewed by 441 users

My Observation

I'm not much of a doctor but I am quite an observer. I watched Carley's death a lot of times ( it's torture ) and I can see that she got hit in her left cheek. Sorry don't know bout' Doug

My stupid reason:

What if some good professional healer "Samaratin" saw him/her and healed him/her. I've watched a lot dramas and somehow those people who get shot in the face or body still manages to survive. Maybe
they will somehow just get an eyepatch or something, but they will still be alive.

53 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • @sparkskel said: Don't tell me the loss of carly isnt serious!..



    Was her death serious? Yes 100%

    Is bringing her back like Dragon Ball Z a serious idea? Yes -100%

  • I think we will know the truth only in the new episode Plaing Deed)I dupt but still hope anyway Situation remains me case with Sherlock Holmes when fans resurrected hero

  • Nah man.

    The only thing they could do is create an addon / patch with additional sequences.

    Lots of games have more content added. I think it would be easier for telltale to release supplementary content later after the pressure of releasing this game is relieved.

    PS: I will totally harass telltale for additional content for this great game when said/done.

    ;)

  • @Redwizards said: Nah man.

    The only thing they could do is create an addon / patch with additional sequences.

    Lots of games have more content added. I think it would be easier for telltale to release supplementary content later after the pressure of releasing this game is relieved.

    PS: I will totally harass telltale for additional content for this great game when said/done.

    ;)



    Interesting idea, but it would only feel fake. :p

    Still 1-up for Carley fans for the continued support.

  • ME3's ending sucked because the game didn't care about what you did.

    TWD's story is awesome because Carley (and Doug) dying is remembered by the rest of the characters and may snap back in subsequent episodes as being important. There are still two left, remember?

  • It would simply not be in TWD spirit.
    The writer wants this scene to stay with us all throughout the game. And maybe even after that.

  • One thing that bugs me about that scene is that only Ben seems to check Carley. Ben, the character who I currently wouldn't even trust to put the cap back on a tube of toothpaste at this moment. If Carley's was still alive and no one bothered to make sure she was gone then Lee and the group truly deserves to be zombie bait.

  • Sadness is a bitch. You couldn't bring your pet dog back just because you really wanted him alive and fictional characters are no different (unless their name is Albert Wesker). Sadly enough, gamers don't seem very good at coping with any shred of loss, when infact it's arguably the next thing besides genuine fear which makes a game leave a lasting effect.

    Nothing in game storytelling is better than seeing loss and fear done right. When a player doesn't land on their feet, and finds themselve sharing identical feelings to his character. Not just watching their character feel something.

    You'll love yourself and the game more later for toughing through it. Much more than you'd appreciate that boring game where only the positive factors stayed permanent. Easy and exciting do not co-exist.

  • It did feel cinematic for the sudden death of Carley, but in my opinion the series wouldn't feel cheapened if she were to reappear. I mean, assume she is alive, and that she took the bullet a la Fight Club, she does know where the group is going, and is fairly competent, more so than some other characters.

    Out of all of the characters (other than Lee), I could only see Carley or Kenny coming back from seemingly insurmountable odds against them. She is tough, well liked and an enjoyable character. For her to make an appearance later, say with a nice scar on the side of her face, would be unexpected and fresh in a fiction that is frequently killing characters off in whichever ways it feels like.

    Now, even with the amount of people that want Carley back, how many of those people are going into Ep4 & Ep5 fully expecting this? Quite near none. I know I'm not. It would be very left field, and if handled right, could be a very good experience. For such a thing to happen it would feel like for once, you get something good to happen to you.

    I understand that the fiction is intentionally dark, but in real life do crappy things constantly, and unrelentingly, with not a single good thing? Perhaps sometimes, but it would break my suspension of disbelief more if the story continued to throw more and more bad things at me, with not a single good event happening. Ep3 culminated with a large amount of deaths, and if it keeps up like this the story will be over-dark, resulting a break in my suspension of disbelief. To bring back a seemingly dead character, especially a well-liked one would be welcoming in its ability to lighten the darkness.

  • Patch episode 3, nuff said.

    "tailored to your play style"
    aka
    "suck my dick faggot player"

Add Comment