User Avatar Image

[SPOILERS]How will *** be remembered in the next episode?

posted by ZombieGoBoom on - last edited - Viewed by 757 users

Probably Carley/Doug were destined to die by Lilly's hand the moment they wrote the script for this game. Even so, I'm still sadden by Carley's death and there is two more episodes to go to change things. Whether TTG have any further plans and surprises or perhaps the storm swirling over her death might get them to alter the story a bit... we can hope.

However, I doubt she can be brought back but I don't mind being wrong here. What I would like to see at least is Carley being mentioned in a few conversations. Lee using her gun. If possible, Lee thinking of her in dream or getting knocked out (or falling on his head will do) and hallucinating. What do you think?

46 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • Before Lee kills Ben....

    You heard it here first!!

  • @Lars80 said: In Meymaneh, Afganistan there was a man shot between his eyes with an AK. And he walked into the ER by himself. So no, a headshot does not have to be fatal. And especially not a cheekshot with a 9mm.

    Carley turned her head, so no one really knows the destination of the bullet. Or where it entered/exited. It could have strafed for all we know.
    When that is said, she is dead.
    Even if she was alive on the ground after being shot there was a zombie coming behind the RV. He would have eaten Carley if she was on the ground breathing and unconcious.

    You argue both sides of this, but still go on about wanting your money back and hating the game. Do you really have an opinion on anything?

  • @Master of Aeons said: You argue both sides of this, but still go on about wanting your money back and hating the game. Do you really have an opinion on anything?

    I know it must be hard in your black and white world to understand that some people can accept that carley got shot and still think the game is not very good.

    I predicted it back in July that Carley/Doug was likely next to go.
    Same with Lilly.
    And i believe Ben. I was wrong about this one.

    As for my opinion.
    My opinion is that the group we gathered in ep1 carried this game up untill ep3. Also, this RPG is very limited and doesnt offer many decisions for me to make. the combat is not very good, just button mashing.
    Try playing games like jagged alliance, ufo: aftermath, brigade E5, kotor or neverwinter knights. I was hoping for a hybrid between those. Id like to organise the raids into Macon to get supplies. Id also like the freedom of deciding who goes and who stays. In addition you can throw in a "story line quest" where you can side with one or the other or stay neutral.
    This is way over telltales head, but it should be doable in 2012.

  • Of course it's doable.

    But do/did they have the budget to make something like that?

    Are any of their other games even remotely like that.

  • You seem to think this is an RPG. No wonder you're disappointed. Telltale and Quantic Dream are two of the only companies working with a format such as this. I'd consider this Telltale's first attempt at it. Quantic Dream's first attempt was Indigo Prophecy. For what it's worth, Walking Dead has more choice than Indigo Prophecy (it's better told too).

    Yeah, Telltale isn't ready for something of that scale yet, but neither was Quantic Dream. I'm pretty sure we're going to get some amazing stuff with this format, it's just going to take a lot more experimentation.

  • LOL Indigo Prophecy.... that was a wild game.

    Not quite Killer 7 wild... but still.

  • wow, look at that poll, Doug's got a silent following in here!

  • @Xarne said: wow, look at that poll, Doug's got a silent following in here!

    Appropriate considering his character. :)

  • @Lars80 said: I know it must be hard in your black and white world to understand that some people can accept that carley got shot and still think the game is not very good.

    I predicted it back in July that Carley/Doug was likely next to go.
    Same with Lilly.
    And i believe Ben. I was wrong about this one.


    I wouldn't speak too soon about Slim Ben just yet...
    I never saw him in the trailer--same way my guts crawled when I noticed Carley didn't appear on the train in any of the trailers...
    *sniff*Car...where did those good times go? We were just warming to each other, too.*sob*

    Anyway, I'd say Slim Ben's chances of survival after this are...
    Slim?
    Heeeell yeah! Dafak are deez people in da woods? :cool:

Add Comment