User Avatar Image

Carly/Doug [Episode 3]

posted by Dwarvster on - last edited - Viewed by 3K users

I feel that the game is very misleading as basically what you say and do will change the outcome of every event/scene that comes about. There must have been a way to save her. Some how to persuade Ben. There must be something or the whole point of what you choose will effect the outcome is a complete bs stunt for buyers.

Put out a DLC or update the game so it is possible to save this character. It would end a lot of arguing and disappointment among these gamers. Thank you.

Doing that would basically tell us gamers/ Walking Dead fans that you as a company actually care about the product and it's consumers. Respect and gratitude will come from this!

Just please let that crucial moment be altered so we can choose the fate of her/him.

Now that that's out there. What do you guys think about the matter?

61 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • @Milosuperspesh said: we all know wilma will NEVER leave fred, i'd date betty but i'd be thinking of wilma.

    Go back to plucking nose hairs with your salad tongs. :p

  • @Milosuperspesh said: we all know wilma will NEVER leave fred, i'd date betty but i'd be thinking of wilma.

    (if you get the reference gimme a hell yeah)

    Flintstones and Red dwarf, I have to leave this thread, I just can't cope with the nostalgic overload anymore :(

  • @Dwarvster said: I feel that the game is very misleading as basically what you say and do will change the outcome of every event/scene that comes about.

    I stopped reading there. They never promised that. They did promise the game will change, but not EVERY scene. Quit lieing to yourself.

  • Not much point in bringing this one back to topic. It's as dead as the subject.

  • @Cyreen said: Not much point in bringing this one back to topic. It's as dead as the subject.

    Badum TISH!

  • i said a 'hell yeah' not more references !! :rolleyes:

    sheesh...

    lol ;)

  • @FarmerJoe said: I liked Carley but all this complaining is starting to taint her for me.
    I'm now starting to wish that Telltale would of kept her alive only for her to meet up with a third survivor at the end of episode 3.

    Dr John. A funny,friendly,handsome and brave man who,a big bonus, brings his vital medical skills to the group. He saves Clementine's life when she gets injured and even risks his own life to save Lee at the beginning of episode 4. Gradually Carley stars to fall for him and by episode 5 they are in a relationship. So Carley first fancied Doug then started to have feelings for Lee but has now found her true soul mate in Dr John.

    I wonder how many would feel satisfied that their favourite character has found true happiness?
    I'd bet the forum would be full of "Fuuuuuuuuuuuuck Yooooooooou Telltale", "WTF, Carley was MINE!!!,"What is this shit, patch it NOW so that Carley loves only me you FUCKING STUPID BASTARDS", "I'm never buying your SHIT AGAIN!!!!" and
    POll:
    1.I'm murdering John when Carley isn't around
    2.John is walker bait the first chance I get
    3.Fuck John and Carley. I'm leaving them both to the herd.

    I'm really starting to wonder if not being allowed the chance for Lee to get his leg over, before Carley died, is fuelling the rage of most of these complaints?


    I was a fan of Carley. It wasn't just about Lee getting his leg over for me. Carly was actually one of the most endearing character in the group. She took an early liking to Lee, the character we control. She gave him the benefit of doubt that he would be trustworthy and kept his secret, establishing herself, early in the story as an ally. Then there are the countless times she has saved Lee and other members in the group.

    Even the walking dead wiki describes Carley as having a more active role in her interactions with the rest of the group than the passive Doug.

    Over the 3 episodes Carley was probably the most consistent character. During my play through she was the person closest to Lee after Clementine. He confided in her, she gave him emotional support and encouragement to step up and take charge of the group in the small role she played in episode 2 and came in handy when she was needed most, at the end. I can't think of another character in Lee's group other than Clementine that had as much meaningful one to one conversations with Lee than Carley did.

    Had she have lived longer I doubt she would have started a relationship with anyone other than Lee, given that it was only 1 week between the events of episode 2's finale and the end of episode 3. Episode 4 continues minutes after episode 3 ends. There wouldn't have been much time for her to establish and build on a relationship with anyone else in the remaining 2 episodes.

    Ben's actions led to the death of Lee's closest companion in the group. I don't disagree with Telltale's discission to kill off Carley but I think they killed her off to early.

  • @N7. said: Why everyone love Carly ? because she was a woman ? she was just an ordinary character

    If you looking for a woman for the sake of God don't play this game


    Why does everyone Like andrea or michonne in the comics the same reason people like Carley, not because she is a woman but because she is badass. Lee is the protagonist and he does not save as much of group members as she has. Lee saved duck/or attempted to save sean at hershels farm(1), he saves Clementine from the walker from the rest room if you get to her in time(2) and the walker at the end of the game(3), he saves Kat from the walker on the truck(4) and when she is a hostage(5) saves Kat when the motor inn is attacked and saves Clementine in the depot office(6)

    Carly saves all 5 of Lee's group from the walkers when they first arrive at Macon(1)She saves Lee a few moments later or Clementine if Lee doesn't save Clementine in time(2) she stops countless zombies from getting to the group during the attack on the pharmacy(3)She saves Lee from the walker he is fighting on the truck(4),She saves Lee from the walker approaching him when he exits the barn(5),She saves Duck and Lee when Andy is pointing his gun at them(6). Had she have lived longer she probably would have saved even more people.

    Then their is the fact that she cares for Lee and Clementine, sacrificing her rations if you offer to feed her and gives reassurance to Lee at crucial times in the story.

  • @bakajin said: Oh come on, let the lads have their fantasy game 2D love interest. Yes, it would be nicer if it were clearer that it is JUST a fantasy, but let the dog ave is bone. A gnawed on, grizzled set of rotting bones, but a bone all the same.


    I don't think it's a matter of gender rather a matter of character. If doug had Carly's character, charisma and energy more people would have warmed to him. doug was a boring, passive character by comparisson. He is more of an observer during the heated debates. Even the walking dead wiki descibes him as passive and Carley as having a more active role in the groups dynamics.

    In the tv show Darayl is probably seen as the most badass of the characters and he is male but in the comic it would probably be Michonne and Andrea and would be considered as such by those watching both the show and reading the graphic novels.

    So the love people have for Carly is not based on her being an attractive character. Christa is just as attractive but she's a bitch and I can't stand her. Carley is the only character in the game who's loyalty is not questioned. Some people are even begining to question Clementine's loyalty since she has not discussed the walkie talkie transmissions she has been receiving, but Carly was an open book, what you saw is what you got and she remainned consistant and was supportive towards Lee through out unlike Kenny who changes in episode 2 and Lilly who changes in episode 3.

  • @dee23 said: Why does everyone Like andrea or michonne in the comics the same reason people like Carley, not because she is a woman but because she is badass. Lee is the protagonist and he does not save as much of group members as she has. Lee saved duck/or attempted to save sean at hershels farm(1), he saves Clementine from the walker from the rest room if you get to her in time(2) and the walker at the end of the game(3), he saves Kat from the walker on the truck(4) and when she is a hostage(5) saves Kat when the motor inn is attacked and saves Clementine in the depot office(6)

    Carly saves all 5 of Lee's group from the walkers when they first arrive at Macon(1)She saves Lee a few moments later or Clementine if Lee doesn't save Clementine in time(2) she stops countless zombies from getting to the group during the attack on the pharmacy(3)She saves Lee from the walker he is fighting on the truck(4),She saves Lee from the walker approaching him when he exits the barn(5),She saves Duck and Lee when Andy is pointing his gun at them(6). Had she have lived longer she probably would have saved even more people.

    Then their is the fact that she cares for Lee and Clementine, sacrificing her rations if you offer to feed her and gives reassurance to Lee at crucial times in the story.

    I liked Carley but please don't dismiss Doug so easily.

    (1)Prior to the events of episode 1 he risked his life to save Carley from walkers and thus caught her eye by his heroic actions ;) (2)Shows such contempt towards the walkers who are attacking the pharmacy that he faces away from them and keeps the window shut with his back (3) Attacks and takes on the truck walker with only a wooden plank not a gun (4) He saves Duck and Lee by distracting an armed man with only a laser pen and thus saves both of them (5) Designed a crucial alarm system that aids Lee in the motel attack by alerting him to oncoming walker threats. (6) Had he lived longer he would of saved even more people. Is it really braver using a gun for every situation? :p

    Doug tells Lee to keep his rations for himself, or to give it to Clem, because he thinks Lee deserves it for saving his life.That's how big hearted and unselfish a guy Doug truly is.

    C'mon, finally Doug died the hero that he was by taking a bullet meant for someone else while Carley died because she didn't know when to shut her mouth :rolleyes:

    Finally he also made me laugh a few times and in a Zombie apocalypse I would greatly appreciate someone who could only make me raise a smile let alone laugh. Carley only has her running gag about the batteries!!!

Add Comment