User Avatar Image

Lilly - Why do people still care?

posted by Pickles312 on - last edited - Viewed by 344 users

Lilly was left on the side of the road or ran away in the RV. Either way she shot Carley or Doug out of cold blood.

So:

1) Why do people still like her?

2) Why do people think she will come bak even though that isn't cannon to the comics?

44 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • The novel and game are both canon to the comics. It's just that there are two different woman named Lilly. The Lilly in the game, and the Lilly in the comic/novel.

  • Both with the same last name and occupation? That's awfully strange.

  • They don't have the same occupation. They do have the same last name, but everything else is very different about them. I agree it's strange to have them have teh same exact name, but nothing else about them is the same.

  • Sorry, the walking dead wiki screwed me up.

    Edit: But once again none of this is said in the actual comics.

  • I hope they leave whether she is comic Lilly ambiguous. I like to think she is, and to me 'Road to Woodbury' doesn't exist. I really liked her character and was interesting seeing how she dealt with the fact my Lee and Kenny killed Larry. Really weird/cool to think that my actions could have caused her to do what she did in the comics. I hope she doesn't return, but not because she killed Carley (I do love to hate her about that though). Plus I don't think Clementine would accept her coming back after what she did.

  • Robert Kirkman trashed out a great female character for his lame novel. I don't particulary like her, but her novel version as a stupid and scared girl was awful compared to the survivalist in the game.

  • The Lilly in the game was awesome and a troublemaker. You can love or hate her but nothing between that. ;)

    I wonder how Lilly reacted when "campman" would tried to get into the group and want revenge on everyone except Lee & Clem. Well Lilly said that "If they come back, then we're just monsters who came out of the woods and ruined their life."

    You better don't mess with Lilly. :D

  • @Kaserkin said: Robert Kirkman trashed out a great female character for his lame novel. I don't particulary like her, but her novel version as a stupid and scared girl was awful compared to the survivalist in the game.



    Really?

    Kirkman may be getting a bit too bold since the series blew up. I mean, a TV show, a video game, another video game on the way (First person shootter), the comics, and now two novels?

  • @Pickles312 said: Exactly, even when you were loyal she backstabbed you. Isn't that enough?



    She was a good person breaking down, I feel pity for her and sympathy. I liked her character, much more than Carley.

  • @Doctanian said: Because she brought tension to the group. The best moments I had besides Clem was arguing with her. She and Kenny's power struggle was a fucking fantastic element that got cut short because the writers wanted to push that lame "Campman" storyline.

    Lilly could've been a major character to the end, yes, she's from the comics, but the TV show obviously doesn't give two fucks considering she hasn't showed up yet, so why should the game?



    I totally agree with it. You always need a troublemaker in the group that get the fans into a discussion. I would had loved to see what would happend with Lilly until the end. How she think about the Crawford situation, how she handled Omid & Christa as new group members and finding secretly out about Christa beeing pregnant.... or also how the situation would had played out w/ Kenny losing Katjaa & Duck, if Lilly would had done it for Kenny.

Add Comment