User Avatar Image

The Choice Thread

posted by TheNNerdGamer on - last edited - Viewed by 798 users

ok so after months season one is finally over.
what where your choices?

my personal where:

Episode 1:
I was honest to Hershel
I saved Duck
I defended Kenny
Refused to give Irene the gun
Saved Doug (first playthrough)/Carley (second)
Episode 2:
I chopped David's leg off
I had Danny shoot Jolene
I killed Larry
I didn't kill any ST.John brothers
I didn't steal from the car
Episode 3:
I didn't shoot the girl in the street
I left Lilly on the road
I talked Kenny down
I shot Duck
I helped Omid
Episode 4:
I killed the boy in the attic
I was honest to Vernon
I brought Clem to Crawford
I pulled Ben up
I showed the bite
I got everyone with me
Episode 5:
I didn't remove Lee's arm
I lost temper with Kenny
I surrendered my weapons
I killed stranger (we all know why)
I had Clem shoot Lee
____________________________________

so what where your choices?
guys remember that you can look at your choices on the stats

29 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • Episode 1:
    I was honest to Hershel
    I saved Shawn
    I did mixed neutral and Kenny, but no Larry.
    Refused to give Irene the gun
    Saved Carley
    Episode 2:
    I chopped David's leg off
    I had Danny shoot Jolene
    I killed Larry
    I didn't kill any ST.John brothers
    I didn't steal from the car
    Episode 3:
    I didn't shoot the girl in the street
    I took Lilly with me.
    I talked Kenny down
    I shot Duck
    I helped Omid
    Episode 4:
    I killed the boy in the attic
    I was honest to Vernon
    I brought Clem to Crawford
    I pulled Ben up
    I showed the bite
    I got everyone but Ben
    Episode 5:
    I didn't remove Lee's arm
    I talked to Kenny and let him grab the sculpture (lol Omid)
    I surrendered my weapons
    I killed stranger
    I had Clem leave Lee

    Lol, 95% of my choices are the same as yours xD

  • Pretty sure I remembered this correctly:

    Episode 1:
    I withheld the truth with Hershel
    I saved Duck
    I defended Kenny
    Helped Irene kill herself
    Saved Doug (reflex... not thought out)
    Episode 2:
    I chopped David's leg off
    I had Danny shoot Jolene
    I killed Larry
    I killed one but spared the other
    I stole from the car
    Episode 3:
    I shot the girl in the street
    I left Lilly on the road
    I talked Kenny down
    I shot Duck
    I helped christa instead of omid (again... reflexively pressed a direction without taking the time to think...)
    Episode 4:
    I killed the boy in the attic
    I was honest to Vernon
    I brought Clem to Crawford
    I dropped Ben's coward, screw-up ass
    I hid the bite
    Only Kenny came with me
    Episode 5:
    I didn't remove Lee's arm
    I lost temper with Kenny
    I surrendered my weapons
    I killed stranger
    I had Clem shoot Lee

  • Episode 1

    - I was honest with Hershel
    - I saved Shawn
    - I defended Kenny
    - I let Irene have the gun
    - I saved Carley

    Episode 2

    - I chopped David's leg off
    - I had Danny shoot Jolene
    - I killed Larry
    - I spared the St. John brothers for the walkers
    - I didn't steal from the car

    Episode 3

    - I left the girl in the street
    - I left Lilly
    - I talked Kenny down
    - I shot Duck
    - I helped Omid

    Episode 4

    - I killed the boy in the attic
    - I was honest to Vernon
    - I brought Clem to Crawford
    - I saved Ben
    - I showed the bite
    - Everyone came with me

    Episode 5

    - I removed Lee's arm
    - I kept calm with Kenny
    - I kept my weapons
    - I killed the stranger
    - I had Clem shoot Lee

  • How do you not lose your temper with Kenny, I chose all the non bad word choices, and even tried to be completely silent.

  • Episode 1:
    I was honest to Hershel
    I saved Duck
    I defended Kenny
    I gave Irene the gun
    Saved Doug
    Episode 2:
    I chopped David's leg off
    I had Danny shoot Jolene
    I killed Larry
    I didn't kill any ST.John brothers
    I took the supplies from the car
    Episode 3:
    I didn't shoot the girl in the street
    I let lilly back in the RV
    I talked Kenny down
    I shot Duck
    I helped Omid
    Episode 4:
    I got kenny to kill the zombie kid
    I was honest to Vernon and not threatening
    I got clementine to stay with omid and gave her the gun
    I pulled Ben up
    I hid the bite
    I got everyone with me
    Episode 5:
    I didn't remove Lee's arm
    I didn't loose my temper with Kenny (but it was heated and later said sorry)
    I didnt touch the statue
    I surrendered my weapons
    I didn't kill the stranger Clementine did
    I told clementine to cuff the zombie
    I had Clem shoot Lee

  • These are the choices that I made:

    Episode 1:
    -Honest with Hershel
    -Chose Duck
    -Defended Kenny
    -Refused the Gun
    -Saved Carley

    Episode 2:
    -Cut David's Leg off
    -Had Danny shoot Jolene
    -Helped Kenny kill Larry
    -Spared Danny and Andy
    -Stole supplies from the car

    Episode 3:
    -Didn't shoot Beatrice
    -Left Lilly on the road
    -Talked Kenny down
    -Had Lee shoot Duck
    -Helped Omid first

    Episode 4:
    -Had Kenny shoot the kid
    -Honest and rational with Vernon
    -Brought Clementine to Crawford
    -Dropped Ben
    -Showed the bite - Omid, Christa and Kenny came with me

    Episode 5:
    -Kept the arm
    -Kept cool with Kenny
    -Surrender weapons
    -Killed the stranger
    -Told Clementine to shoot Lee

  • Episode 1

    Semi-honest with Hershel
    Saved Duck
    Defended Kenny
    Didn't give the gun to Irene (Where the fuck did this name come from?)
    Saved Carley

    Episode 2

    Cut David free
    Let Danny shoot Jolene
    Helped Kenny to kill Larry
    Didn't kill Danny or Andy
    Didn't take the food

    Episode 3

    Didn't shoot the girl
    Left Lilly
    Fought Kenny (I didn't intend to, but he just randomly got pissed off and tried to whoop my ass, so I beat him down :D)
    Shot Duck
    Helped Omid (I thought I should help him, because he hurt his leg.)

    Episode 4

    Killed the kid
    Threatened Vernon
    Took Clementine to Crawford
    Saved Ben
    Showed the bite
    Got Christa, Omid, and Kenny to come with me (Ben left behind)

    Episode 5

    Had the arm cut off
    I kept calm with Kenny
    Kept the cleaver
    Choked the fucker with one hand
    Had Clem shoot Lee

  • Episode 1:
    I was honest to Hershel - I don't quite get why people would lie to him.
    I saved Shawn - I don't really know why, should have saved Duck.
    I defended Kenny - Gave hell to larry, thought the "NO" option would be less violent. This is the only time i rewound my save file.
    Gave Irenne the gun - She would turn and we would have to shoot her later: Why not prevent her from turning? She was dead one way or another.
    Saved Carley - I liked her and got to spend more time with her than I did with Doug. Doug was an okay guy, I liked him.

    Episode 2:
    I chopped David's leg off
    I shot Jolenne - Accidentally /lol
    I tried to save Larry - It WAS risky, since we didn't know (I didn't know) if he would make it. I also tried killing him on a second alt save file: I hated how you had to drag Lilly away from his Larry :(
    I didn't kill any ST.John brothers - Spared Danny's life, and Andy got paralyzed (but not killed) by his own electrified fence.
    I didn't steal from the car - Telling the other about to starve survivors wouldn't get them to stop looting the car, I figured out they would still take it and I thought it's owner might had been alive (unlikely, since the car ran out of fuel, the keys were still on, and everything. but well... episode 5..)

    Episode 3:
    I shot Beatrice - I just had to shoot her.
    I brought Lilly with me - everyone could have a mental breakdown in a ZA, and I would like people supporting me if I had just lost everything I had. I'm not saying that Lilly's decissions were the best (Carley/Doug), but I dont know how I would have reacted in her shoes.
    I fought with Kenny - I didn't want to, but somehow I still had to do it.
    I shot Duck - If I had kids of my own, I wouldn't want to be the one putting them out of their missery. Specially not after losing the love of my life.
    I helped Omid - Saving a young, fit woman wearing a sports jacket over a recently injured guy: Really?

    Episode 4:
    I killed the boy in the attic - Both of the options here are indirectly helping Kenny.
    I was honest to Vernon - Again, why lying?
    I brought Clem to Crawford - She is always safer when Lee is taking care of her. Besides, there was the Radio guy (Stranger) stalking us.
    I pulled Ben up
    I showed the bite - Once again, WHY lying?
    I got everyone with me - Kenny didn't give me his bro speech, but he came with me anyways.

    Episode 5:
    I didn't remove Lee's arm - Lee was already feeling sick, meaning the infection already had spread thru his body. Besides, he could have needed his arm later.
    I lost temper with Kenny - Snowball Statue fight!
    I surrendered my weapons - He would have just got more pissed if he found out Lee still had weapons, and I would (i guess) have reacted fast enough to take his gun away.
    I killed stranger - yeah..
    I had Clem shoot Lee - If she could shoot Lee, she could shoot anyone afterwards. She had to go through this.

  • @xXNinjaScoreXx said: How do you not lose your temper with Kenny, I chose all the non bad word choices, and even tried to be completely silent.

    Shit happens, I suppose.

  • Episode 1:
    ~I was honest with Hershel.
    ~I saved Duck.
    ~I defended Kenny.
    ~I refused to give Irene the gun.
    ~I saved Carley.

    Episode 2:
    ~I chopped David's leg off.
    ~I had Danny shoot Jolene.
    ~I tried to save Larry.
    ~I killed one of the St. John's brothers.
    ~I didn't steal from the car.

    Episode 3:
    ~I shot Beautrice.
    ~I left Lilly on the road.
    ~I talked Kenny down.
    ~I shot Duck.
    ~I helped Omid.

    Episode 4:
    ~I killed the boy in the attic.
    ~I was honest with Vernon
    ~I brought Clem with me to Crawford.
    ~I pulled Ben up.
    ~I showed the others my bite.
    ~I brought everyone with me.

    Episode 5:
    ~I removed Lee's arm.
    ~I lost temper with Kenny.
    ~I didn't surrender my weapons.
    ~I had Clem kill the stranger.
    ~I had Clem shoot Lee.

Add Comment