89 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • @ColtPeacemaker00 said: Duck, if Duck hadn't died Katjaa wouldn't have killed herself, and assuming they had made it to episode 5 Kenny wouldn't feel inclined to sacrifice himself and leave his family. So in saving Duck I would have saved three lives. Besides Iliked the kid.

    Like I said, Just letting you all know there are no free spells here. Saving duck only saves Duck. Saving Larry only saves Larry. No ways to cheat into saving more than one.

  • Duck would probably be my no. 1 choice. If Duck wasn't bit, Katjaa wouldn't be demoralized to the point where she'd end her own life, and Kenny wouldn't become a despondent automaton through the remainder of the game (or at least until you find the boat in Savannah).

  • Probably Kat. Just because if she's still alive, Kenny probably doesn't throw his life away like he did.

  • @montesinos7 said: Like I said, Just letting you all know there are no free spells here. Saving duck only saves Duck. Saving Larry only saves Larry. No ways to cheat into saving more than one.

    but if a death is directly responsible for another, duck for katjaa, its logical to presume that the prevention of the first would prevent the second, if duck did not get bit katjaa would not have killed herself and kenny would not have sacrificed himself for ben/krista if his family were still alive. it would not be a question of "magic spells", but of a simple and logical progression of a chain of altered events resulting directly from the first.

  • @ColtPeacemaker00 said: but if a death is directly responsible for another, duck for katjaa, its logical to presume that the prevention of the first would prevent the second, if duck did not get bit katjaa would not have killed herself and kenny would not have sacrificed himself for ben/krista if his family were still alive. it would not be a question of "magic spells", but of a simple and logical progression of a chain of altered events resulting directly from the first.


    I don't think you got the point of his post... He was saying you can only save one, just one. It doesn't matter if you saving, say, Duck would result in more people being saved. In this poll you're just saving one.

  • @ColtPeacemaker00 said: but if a death is directly responsible for another, duck for katjaa, its logical to presume that the prevention of the first would prevent the second, if duck did not get bit katjaa would not have killed herself and kenny would not have sacrificed himself for ben/krista if his family were still alive. it would not be a question of "magic spells", but of a simple and logical progression of a chain of altered events resulting directly from the first.

    Thats just not the point of the thread, its about picking one character you wished had made it, In true walking dead fashion your decision doesn't change the overall plot :p, just say that if you save duck then Kat and Kenny get eaten by walkers.


    That said trying to find a good chain of events might be more fun.

    How about if you stop Bens teacher falling into the bear trap, Ben never joins the group so he never tells them the bite doesn't make you turn, Therefore Kenny has no reason to kill Larry in the meat locker so Lilly never flies of the handle and never kills Carley, while fact Ben never deals with the bandits means Duck is never bitten, Kat never kills herself and Kenny doesn't lose the will to live, Finally with Carley/Katjaa still around to mother Clem she never trusts the stranger and never gets kidnapped, so Lee isn't bitten.

    Instant happy ending, beat that.

  • @The Fallen said: How about if you stop Bens teacher falling into the bear trap, Ben never joins the group so he never tells them the bite doesn't make you turn, Therefore Kenny has no reason to kill Larry in the meat locker so Lilly never flies of the handle and never kills Carley, while fact Ben never deals with the bandits means Duck is never bitten, Kat never kills herself and Kenny doesn't lose the will to live, Finally with Carley/Katjaa still around to mother Clem she never trusts the stranger and never gets kidnapped, so Lee isn't bitten.

    God dammit, Ben!

  • @The Fallen said: Thats just not the point of the thread, its about picking one character you wished had made it, In true walking dead fashion your decision doesn't change the overall plot :p, just say that if you save duck then Kat and Kenny get eaten by walkers.


    That said trying to find a good chain of events might be more fun.

    How about if you stop Bens teacher falling into the bear trap, Ben never joins the group so he never tells them the bite doesn't make you turn, Therefore Kenny has no reason to kill Larry in the meat locker so Lilly never flies of the handle and never kills Carley, while fact Ben never deals with the bandits means Duck is never bitten, Kat never kills herself and Kenny doesn't lose the will to live, Finally with Carley/Katjaa still around to mother Clem she never trusts the stranger and never gets kidnapped, so Lee isn't bitten.

    Instant happy ending, beat that.

    And what if Larry really did die in the meat locker and Kenny was right for smashing his head open? Then everyone dies because Ben was never there to warn them that you come back no matter how you die and Zombie Larry murders everybody. :p

  • @Jaded X Gamer said: And what if Larry really did die in the meat locker and Kenny was right for smashing his head open? Then everyone dies because Ben was never there to warn them that you come back no matter how you die and Zombie Larry murders everybody. :p

    Hey not everybody... maybe Carley could save Katjaa and Duck then they could return to the motel to face the murdering, raping bandits by themselves... Ok there's two very distinct ways my idea could turn out :p

Add Comment