User Avatar Image

Who did you tell about Lee's past?

posted by Zeruis on - last edited - Viewed by 620 users

Let's revisit a key point from episode 3 if you saved Carley.

Who did you tell about Lee's past, and why?

-I only told Katjaa and Lilly. At the time, I thought that Katjaa was a caring woman, and she would've understood what Lee went through. I also told Lilly because she was the next person I could trust in the group. I didn't care about Kenny at all during the first twenty minutes of the episode.

EDIT: Sigh, I forgot to post multiple options in the poll. Oh well.

23 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • I chose Clem in the poll - but quite frankly I told everyone, Clem deserved it the most though. Anyways, I can't keep secrets too good in real life, and so I couldn't do it in this game either, it was clear to me, that they'd find out anyways.

  • Everyone but Ben. Even though Kenny was being a real ass to me at the time, I thought about what Carley said how the longer I waited the more it seemed like I had to hide and I figured if Kenny heard it any other way it would torpedo what was left of our friendship so I figured it was best to just get it out of the way.

    Lilly was easy since she was mostly focused on hating Kenny at the time and I figured she really wouldn't give a shit and Katjaa and Clem were always fair with Lee so I felt they simply deserved to know the truth. Kinda regret telling Kat about what happened in the meat locker. Figured if Kenny knew I told her that it'd kill any little goodwill trusting him with my secret did but so much happened after that it never came up.

    I didn't tell Ben because I hadn't known him all that long, I wasn't sure I could trust him yet and it didn't seem like a big deal if he heard the truth from someone else. I mean Kenny could ditch me and Lilly was going crazy, but what the fuck would Ben do if he found out Lee killed somebody? He'd probably just be afraid of him. :p

  • Everyone but Lilly.

    Because fuck Lilly, that's why :cool:

  • I told everyone. I had a sort of brutal honesty thing going on since episode 1, meaning i tell everyone everything about me, with one exception for Clem. I never told her that her parents were dead, but as for everything else I've got nothing to hide.

  • I told everyone, even the newcomer Ben.

    Carley was right that keeping Lee's conviction a secret is a liability and he should come clean before the others found out the hard way. I was hesistant to reveal the truth to Kenny since I sided against him with the meatlocker incident, but I figured that he's better off knowing than never considering his mood at the time.

  • Hey, here's a good follow up question. Did you tell people you killed someone or that you were on your way to prison? I said to everyone I told I killed before. I figured saying I went to prison was kinda dodging the issue and it would just lead to people asking "What for?" Best just give them the whole truth so there's nothing left to be used against me.

  • @Jaded X Gamer said: Hey, here's a good follow up question. Did you tell people you killed someone or that you were on your way to prison? I said to everyone I told I killed before. I figured saying I went to prison was kinda dodging the issue and it would just lead to people asking "What for?" Best just give them the whole truth so there's nothing left to be used against me.

    I just told them that I was a murdering bastard because I didn't feel like extending the conversation any further than needed.

  • I told all of them during my second playthrough. The first time i did not tell anyone, same with the bite.

  • Kenny and Clementine,

    They were the two i felt i had the most to lose if they discovered i was lying to them. Lilly already knew and already hated me, in short she was the problem so that was never an option. Katjaa had enough on her mind/i wasn't sure how she'd react and Ben was....Ben.

    As for how i broke the news, i was direct with Ken, thought he'd appreciate some blunt honest and he more than anyone else really needed to hear it from me, played the softer hand when talking to Clem, I was a bit worried about what she might think, but needed her to be able to trust me.

  • Godamn everyone. I knew someone would sell me out eventually, and Carley, Clem and Lilly already knew, Kenny had my back at that point, Ben would be too terrified to ever even attempt to use it against me, and he needed someone on his side too, and finally Katjaa is a very understanding and caring person. Even if all that wasn't true, I knew it would bite me very hard in the arse otherwise.

Add Comment