User Avatar Image

If Lily returns...

posted by That1Guy on - last edited - Viewed by 383 users

Would you forgive her for shooting Carley/Doug if she helped the PC?

57 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • @Rock114 said: Now now now, Kiel, do we KNOW, for certain, that everyone's favorite redneck is dead? For all we know, he was hiding a katana in that moustache of his. Perhaps that's his version of Lee's infinite, invisible pockets. Until I see a body, I can't write him off.



    You mean his mustache is the katana? That thing looks sharp :3

  • @zev_zev said: Of course! The cemetery is the most suitable place to hide during ZA! :D



    Of course it is. Who in their sane mind would go in there? Not me, but I'm not sane :D

  • @Rock114 said: Now now now, Kiel, do we KNOW, for certain, that everyone's favorite redneck is dead? For all we know, he was hiding a katana in that moustache of his. Perhaps that's his version of Lee's infinite, invisible pockets. Until I see a body, I can't write him off.



    Well of course he's alive! I see him right there next to Capt. Carley on the good ship denial :D. You know they are waiting for you...best get a move on.

    Seriously though...He's KIA. The reason there is no body is because the walker swarm he was under did not leave any scraps left. I told him to forget about the radio but I guess he really felt a connection with Christa who he just met what a day and a half ago and jumped in after her....must have been love at first sight :D.

  • @Kiel555 said: Well of course he's alive! I see him right there next to Capt. Carley on the good ship denial :D. You know they are waiting for you...best get a move on.

    Seriously though...He's KIA. The reason there is no body is because the walker swarm he was under did not leave any scraps left. I told him to forget about the radio but I guess he really felt a connection with Christa who he just met what a day and a half ago and jumped in after her....must have been love at first sight :D.



    I don't like your sarcasm -_- BUT YES, ALL ABOARD!

  • @Kiel555 said: Well of course he's alive! I see him right there next to Capt. Carley on the good ship denial :D. You know they are waiting for you...best get a move on.

    Seriously though...He's KIA. The reason there is no body is because the walker swarm he was under did not leave any scraps left. I told him to forget about the radio but I guess he really felt a connection with Christa who he just met what a day and a half ago and jumped in after her....must have been love at first sight :D.



    Or... you know... REDEMPTION. And Kenny wanted to leave the radio too, so he was lost saving a pregnant woman from certain death, quite possibly (but NOT certainly) at the cost of his own life.

    And, sir, I'll GLADLY take a ride on that good ship. I just hope First Mate Larry doesn't punch me off of it for what I did in the meat locker... :D

  • @Mark$man said: First of all, by the time Vernon steals the boat you already realize that the walkers came from the train.

    I don't think Vernon thought about taking the boat until after talking to you privately.

    The fact of the matter is, people are going to care about themselves and their group over anyone else. You see that even in your own group, and truth is you are forced to as well.

    I don't mean to say that Vernon is a GREAT guy or that he should be trusted, but cut the guy some slack. He doesn't deserve to be murdered in his sleep. His act was probably as bad as Ben stealing from the group, which many people didn't seem to care about until it caused Carley, Katjaa, and Duck's deaths. I just don't see what the big deal is. Yeah, he did a bad thing, but truthfully it was also the right thing. If I knew another group had a boat and it was good to go, I'd probably try to steal it too, especially if there is a horde coming. Btw, the horde was our fault, the group signed their own death warrant.



    We do eventually learn that, but we could have been more prepared for the horde if Vernon had said "well it's surrounded by thousands of walkers!" when he asks about it.

    I wouldn't kill him or even hurt him because of what he did, but if he came to our people(Christa/Omid/Kenny/Clem) for refuge, it would take a long time for him to earn my trust back. It's different than Ben because Ben's screw-up meant no harm. At first he did it to try to save a friend(which he probably would have tried to bring to the group if they really had him) and then he kept doing it thinking he was keeping the group safe. He was dead wrong, of course, but it's the thought that counts.

    Vernon on the other hand, did his bad deed by willingly doing harm to our group. I honestly rank him just behind the St. Johns on my enemy list. They were doing things to support themselves over others, as well...and i let them both live(not that it did them much of a favor).

    It's just how i am regarding this stuff. I tried to reason with Jolene, i shot Beatrice, i didn't want to steal from the station wagon, i saved Ben, i tried to save Larry...everyone matters just as much as my own group, and if that attitude gets me killed in the first days during a widespread apocalyptic event(and it probably would)...so be it.

    Vernon is not a follower of my signature, so i will not be cutting any slack for him.

  • @Rock114 said: Or... you know... REDEMPTION. And Kenny wanted to leave the radio too, so he was lost saving a pregnant woman from certain death, quite possibly (but NOT certainly) at the cost of his own life.

    And, sir, I'll GLADLY take a ride on that good ship. I just hope First Mate Larry doesn't punch me off of it for what I did in the meat locker... :D



    Ha ha First Mate Larry :D. At least He's finally putting all that charm to good use!

    Larry and Kenny have a lot of catching up to do. Have a nice cruise.:D

  • Something tells me Kenny and I would be walkin' the plank... Hell, we'll go skinny dippin'! Serves the old man right xD

  • @That1Guy said: Would you forgive her for shooting Carley/Doug if she helped the PC?



    HELL NO

    God I hate her, I loved Carley.


    @That1Guy said: Why wouldn't he have...? ... Never mind... I don't want to know. Idk, I just want him to be alive.

    Same.

  • I can already imagine my look if I found out Kenny was alive for real, and if I am walking the plank with Kenny, then I am dragging Lilly down with us all.

Add Comment