User Avatar Image

Why Doug Fans ?

posted by master psychic on - last edited - Viewed by 508 users

I noticed that Doug fans have a tendency to criticize people who saved Carley over Doug just because many people saved her than Doug and all of them say that the people who saved her want boobies , and that she is hot etc .
I saved Carley and i don't criticize the people who saved Doug , both of them are great characters , so why ?
Why do you Doug fans have such a grudge against Carley fans and the people who saved her ? Is it because Telltale wants us all to save him ?
Just because Telltale wants us to save him that doesn't mean everyone will do the same choice , anyone can make different choices and have different motives .
I saved Carley because she is trustworthy and she always saves Lee from danger , does that mean that I saved her because i want boobs ?
I don't want to start a flame war , i just want to understand why Doug fans are angry at Carley fans and always jump to conclusions about their motives .

35 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • @michikade said: Yeah, she could have put a heel through the one walker's head and used her pistol as a melee weapon, whereas Doug was held in such a way that his arms were pinned down.


    Do the math, to stomp you'd first need to lift your foot... A walker was tugging at her other foot. Essentially she would have tumbled over. She was wearing flats anyways. I seriously doubt she would have the strength to bash the walker's head in by kicking at it either. Furthermore the one grabbing her foot wasn't the inmediate danger, the swarm heading right at her was. I have no doubt in my mind if she went down to bludgeon the walker she would have been devoured before she managed to unclench the hand off her ankle. Her energy was best spent trying to get Lee's attention and preparing to catch the magazine (if she was busy bludgeoning the walker and failed to catch the magazine... well she would have died). She was probably shitting her pants panicking too.

  • Blunt or not, that heel could've one through the walker's eye and into the brain. I always did think her footing would have been...precarious... to say the least, had she attempted it. But at the same time, it's hard to feel sorry for her when Doug has arms wrapped around his chest from several different walkers who are trying to yank him out into the street and do what walkers do best to him.

  • @Rock114 said: Blunt or not, that heel could've one through the walker's eye and into the brain.


    I don't think so. A human skull is freakin' tough as hell and Carley is a tiny little girl. Unless she tried to crush it through an eye socket, but that would require a lot of precision, something she probably wouldn't even be able to do if she wasn't panicking. She was wearing flats anyways, the heel on those puppies are next to nonexistant.
    I always did think her footing would have been...precarious... to say the least, had she attempted it. But at the same time, it's hard to feel sorry for her when Doug has arms wrapped around his chest from several different walkers who are trying to yank him out into the street and do what walkers do best to him.
    Well he's the one who thought it'd be a good idea to barricade a fucked window with his back..

  • @CarScar said: Well he's the one who thought it'd be a good idea to barricade a fucked window with his back..

    Well, someone had to block it. Otherwise there would be tons of walkers pouring in from yet another location, and that might have allowed them to block the exit and kill everyone inside the store. I think it was a necessary sacrifice.

  • @CarScar said: I don't think so. A human skull is freakin' tough as hell and Carley is a tiny little girl. Unless she tried to crush it through an eye socket, but that would require a lot of precision, something she probably wouldn't even be able to do if she wasn't panicking. She was wearing flats anyways, the heel on those puppies are next to nonexistant.

    Well he's the one who thought it'd be a good idea to barricade a fucked window with his back..

    Maybe I just have more sympathy for Doug because he didn't have a gun, but she just didn't seem to be in as much danger as poor Doug. And if he hadn't put his back against that barricade, there's a good chance the walkers would have gotten through, and none of the characters would have survived for us to have this discussion. Just because it's not the smartest thing to do, doesn't mean there's an alternative.

  • if's buts and maybe's

    should've,could've, would've.

    i reckon doug had a lousy poker face anyway

  • If Doug would play poker, he would probably cheat by using his trusty bell and wire system.

  • I'm not attracted to boobies and I still saved her first. I thought if I saved her she'd use her gun to save Doug. I'm going to do a Doug playthrough to see how it compares...

  • Savinf doug works better for me because of the shock value of carlys death, like if it was a tv show and we were watching, we would be pretty suprised at her death as it looks like she was going to be a main character, she saved lee's life, went on a mission with lee and even knows his secret.

  • I liked both so I saved her in one play and Doug in another

Add Comment