User Avatar Image

Lilly or Clementine

posted by master psychic on - last edited - Viewed by 662 users

I see that some people really love Lilly and would rather die for her than for Clem so here's the scenario :
Let's say that you get the option of going with Lilly and later she gets grabbed by 10 walkers and Clem gets grabbed by 3 walkers who you would save Lilly or Clem
If you save Lilly , Clementine dies and she demands to know why did you save her over Clem and here are the options
1 You are my new reason to live
2 Clementine isn't important
3 She was a burden
And after you choose one of those options Lilly is still not satisfied and Lee says something like " by staying with you , you made me realize that Clem is just another mouth to feed " and that he should of just left her alone from the beggining and that he really loves Lilly and that being with her he is much than with Clem .
Or if you save Clem Lilly dies and both of them decide to go on their own path
So you would guys save Clem over Lilly or decide that Lilly is much important than Clem .
Edit : when i said both of them decide to go on their own path i meant both of them stay together as a team and find a save heaven

59 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • I have the DNA of many forum members Kenny and Nate created me....

  • Yes yes it does (phineas and ferb reference, yeah I watch that show)

  • No problem coming from me, I do watch cartoons sometimes to.

  • ...I don't even know why this is being asked.

    Your asking me to choose between Lily - the girl who shoots my friend Carly (who I'm very "fond" of and may I add is always there for me, keeps my secret and saves me from walkers when saving Clem) and who's dad hates my guts and leaves me for dead without even giving me a chance vs. the little girl who saves me from a walker before she even knows me and then forms a very strong bond with who I've and I quote "been through more together than you could imagine. Anyone who tries to get between me and her - anyone! - is gonna wind up dead!"

    Yeah. Clem all the way! :D
    Once Lily shot Carley that was it. I didn't have to think twice about leaving her sorry ass behind. :P

  • @TeamKennyAlways said: I have the DNA of many forum members Kenny and Nate created me....

    I can see it now.

    Nate: Shit, bro, he's almost done. I think he's missin' somethin' though.
    Kenny: Got it. *Pours in whiskey*

  • Hahahahaha *wipes away tear of laughter* My cheeks hurt from smiling and laughing so much

    That's exactly what happened Rock.

  • It's alive, and will be forever think of us as great idols, are mission is complete.

  • @HelloCthulhu said: Is this even a thing now? People are really considering trading lilly for clementine? REALLY?! I mean consider this: Lilly was meant to be the same lilly in the comics. The one who goes to Woodbury...the one who murders an infant...this is who we are voting on?


    By mistake! You make out like the Lilly in the comics went up to the kid Terminator style and blew it away. She didn't even know that the person she was aiming at was holding a kid and she didn't know that the person she was aiming at was innocent. She thought the fleeing people were a threat to Woodbury and shot on command.

    If people are gonna talk smack about the Lilly in the comics they should at least read it. I don’t mean to sound “arsey” but the Lilly in the comics is misunderstood partly because of negative rumours passed around about her to and from people that haven’t read the comics which is probably why Kirkman felt the need to do her back story to show that she isn’t the evil sociopath people are claiming her to be and never was. Lilly is a survivor, will do what it takes to survive but she has morals and would never kill a kid deliberately.

  • @Bioshock Infinite WD said: And are you a clone of a clone of me, or are we all the same person from other universes but we just do not know it yet...


    You can't make a clone from a clone! Things get... Iffy.
    @Bioshock Infinite WD said: By mistake! You make out like the Lilly in the comics went up to the kid Terminator style and blew it away. She didn't even know that the person she was aiming at was holding a kid and she didn't know that the person she was aiming at was innocent. She thought the fleeing people were a threat to Woodbury and shot on command.
    So she has no culpability? Please.

    @Bioshock Infinite WD said: If people are gonna talk smack about the Lilly in the comics they should at least read it.


    Actually... I have read the comics, and she is just as much of a murderer there as she was with Carly/Doug. About as flaky of a reason for not taking responsibility there too. She didn't know that the people at the prison were innocent because she never bothered to question anything. Blind obedience is just as bad as informed consent.

Add Comment