User Avatar Image

Hardest choice In game?

posted by StalkerWalker on - last edited - Viewed by 1.1K users

let the fans decide!!!

24 Comments - Linear Discussion: Classic Style
  • Lets hope for more of that stuff so we can lose are minds again.

  • I always had to choose the geek...
    I would never let someone suffer as bait...
    I would never drop Ben no matter what he's done...
    I had to feed the Kids and Mark and at the time Kenny was the least hostile...
    I could never kill in front of Clem
    I would try anything to save Lee
    I would never steal
    Doug fans couldn't tell people about their past
    But Larry...
    It was tense, a man was dying, we were all in danger and my only Ally was attempting to force me to murder a man whilst he could be saved...
    Compared to the other choices it was hard but I would never betray my morals and kill someone...

  • @Hudomonkey said: I always had to choose the geek...
    I would never let someone suffer as bait...
    I would never drop Ben no matter what he's done...
    I had to feed the Kids and Mark and at the time Kenny was the least hostile...
    I could never kill in front of Clem
    I would try anything to save Lee
    I would never steal
    Doug fans couldn't tell people about their past
    But Larry...
    It was tense, a man was dying, we were all in danger and my only Ally was attempting to force me to murder a man whilst he could be saved...
    Compared to the other choices it was hard but I would never betray my morals and kill someone...


    I don't drop Ben, I aim at the walker behind him but take too long to shoot and the walker bites him and pulls him down the shaft. Then I tell Clem I tried to save him. My conscience is clear. It would be a bit sinister to let him go if you are holding him so I don't take the shot.

  • I would have to say Larry. I hated him but killing him infront of Lily and Clem when your not even sure he's dead? I couldn't do it even though I completely understood Kennys reasons. I didn't like the guy but I still tried to save him so my conscience is clear. :)
    Ofcourse if I knew Lily was going to shoot Carly in the next episode... but hey, I play the nice guy!

  • Ben's fate was the hardest one for me. In the end I figured I'd pull him up, though part of me wanted to drop him because of all the deaths he's caused. And seriously, removing that hatchet was stupid EVEN FOR BEN. When he did that I swore to myself that was the last straw. But I still pulled him up, figuring if I really need to get rid of him, I'll do it later. And maybe, just MAYBE he'll do something useful for a change (spoiler alert: he didn't).

    Larry was a close second, but not as hard. I felt no remorse killing him. Not that I specifically wanted him to die, but really, he brought this on himself- he knows he has a heart condition, he knows he could keel over any minute from stress, and yet he continues to pound the fucking door and shout obscenities nobody cares about. If Clementine wasn't in that locker, I would have tried to save him, but no way I was gonna allow her to be put in danger just because Larry couldn't stop and think for a second.

  • Who to feed, I was afraid that something was gonna happen afterwards like the people who you didn't give food to would end up dying of hunger later on in the episode so I made sure that I gave it to the people I liked.

  • The Larry choice was easy (Kenny FTW)
    Ben choice was too (pulled him up)
    Shoot Lee or no, easy (left him)
    All the others were really easy except Doug or Carley.

    I spent months making that decision, I had to replay that part at least 20 times. The week before Episode 2 came out, I figured I'll just pick Doug.

  • Larry.Kenny's my bro and i don't wanna let him down,
    but killing someone next to Clementine is hard..
    i end up killing him.

  • Killing Larry or attempting to save him. I ended up killing him because he was a douche, and it was only a matter of time before he would have another episode during a zombie or bandit attack

  • Doug or Carley
    -Carley. No contest.

    Larry: save or kill?
    -Kill. I agreed 100% with Kenny's view on that situation.

    Leave her as bait or put out of misery ( episode 3 )
    -Bait. Seriously guys. This is a no brainer. Nobody gave a second thought to that guy stuck in the bear trap if we failed to free him (I was one last chop away from doing so to..). No one gave HIM a mercy shot, and there was plenty of time to finish him before running.

    Ben : Drop or pull up
    -... This was, by far, the hardest decision for me. I look at this list and there isn't a single other one that was even remotely hard. I so wanted to have him die. I really, REALLY, wanted to let him die. I had a really intense hatred for him at that point. He was in directly responsible for several deaths at that point. But in the end I just couldn't justify it to myself, so I helped him up.


    What to do with duck
    -Kill him myself. No way I was letting Kat or Kenny do it.

    Take the food or not ( episode 2 )
    -Take the food. I was starving. Christ. If anyone really felt bad about it we could have left a note telling them where to visit to get the supplies back.

    Who to feed
    -Clem & Duck. They are the kids. Mark. Special consideration should go to the guy that gave us food to last for much longer then we would have otherwise. Larry, because the squeaky wheel gets the cheese and I didn't want to deal with his whining.

    who to tell about your past
    Tell. Told everyone. I wasn't dumb enough to think for a moment that I could realistically hide it so I jumped at the chance to diffuse the situation.

    Cut off arm or not
    Cut it off. CUT IT OFF! GET THAT BITE OFF ME!!! Even if it doesn't work, it still gives information as to how long you have before trying to cut off a limb is a useless endeavor.

    Fate of the St Johns
    I didn't feel like murdering them but, if they hadn't been killed off by zombies at the end, I would have backed up to a save point and done the deed.
    Last words to clem
    It was a bit difficult I suppose. I don't remember everything I picked.

    Choosing favorite episode ( lol )
    I can pick least favorite episode really easy (number 3). Eh, not really sure.


    I think the 'let Lilly come or be left behind' choice should have been added. I've watched several playthroughs and everyone of them cried when Carley got killed (all of the playthroughs I saw picked Carley) and everyone of them dropped Lilly without a second thought. AND YET, a lot of people brought her along. Who are these people that made that choice? Doing so couldn't have been easy for them if they felt as bad about Carley/Doug dying as I and the playthrough guys did.

Add Comment