Who was your first suspect with the broken flashlight?

[Zombies are Awesome!]

As the title says, When you first questioned everyone about it, Who was your first suspect?

[Master of Aeons]

There were no suspects. Just those people I knew and the new guy.

[Kartonnendozen]

For some reason Clem. because she may have felled guilty about stealing from the car.

[Matrox Yang]

There should be a "didn't really care" option because for me it seemed that it was only Lilly who was super angry about the situation.

[thestalkinghead]

i was more concerned with the missing drugs, the flash light had potential for not being connected at all

[PandaRave]

I thought duck (Robin) before he wanted to help me. :D

[Phantom Command]

Although the story tries to make you think "Clem what have you done" with the whole chak thing I saw through it as the bandits previous history with little girls wasn't to nogotiate a peace treaty.

Unfortantly I thought Ben stright away and grew more and more furious with him as he continued to lie to my face, I turned into Lilly Jr during the RV vote.

[YamiRaziel]

I thought it was Carley :D Ben felt like the obvious choice and her flirting with me was the perfect cover up for a traitor :p

Unfortantly I thought Ben stright away and grew more and more furious with him as he continued to lie to m face, I turned into Lilly Jr during the RV vote.

Haha, that made me laugh. Unfortunately I don't think the game allows you get like really angry

[DreadMagus]

Ben... it was pretty obvious.

[IndigoHawk]

My first guess was Kenny about the missing drugs. He hates Lilly's leadership and wants to leave so badly that I thought he was skimming supplies in preparation of leaving. Kenny didn't back me up in the barn even though I went out to back him up ... and he seems to have forgotten I helped save his kid. I thought Kenny was a selfish coward at this point, and I could see him stealing from the group.

For the flashlight, maybe Kenny was sneaking the supplies outside of the motel at night so that they wouldn't be found in a search of the RV. The chalk x didn't fit with that theory, though, as it looked like a signal.

[RedKoolLoops]

I voted Carley as I spoke to Carley first and she was acting... odd. I then realised that it was more than likely Ben until the first conversation at the train. It annoyed me how Ben sounded angry when you questioned him just as you arrived at it, even going as far as lying to your face. The pure cheek of him.

[Zeruis]

I originally thought it was Lilly. Because Lilly was leaving for Woodbury soon, I thought that she did it and she was forced to leave the group because of that reason.

[Rock114]

Ben. I had been through so much with everyone else that I was more than willing to give them the benefit of the doubt. I didn't know Ben. He didn't get that luxury.

[Viser]

I actually had no idea who it could have been. Everyone could have had their reasons to do it, but I only showed it to Doug, Kenny/Katjaa and Duck later on. The flashlight being broken didn't bother me as much as it did Lilly, though.

[Wrighty]

I thought it was actually Lilly. She thought people would ask about the flashlight she broke, panicked, then told Lee do he wouldn't suspect her if anyone noticed. I also thought she might have been taking the drugs to get over Larrys death.

Kinda makes sense.

[Milosuperspesh]

repeat thread peeps link to my 'the traitor thread'

http://www.telltalegames.com/forums/showthread.php?t=32324

to be on topic i thought larry/lilly since larry was always on about being fed and keeping lilly safe.. also for her to shift the blame on to lee or others was a simple misdirection but when i played ep3 i was leanign towards carley she got very defensive when i asked her..and then talking to ben after kinda made me suspect himit was only after carley died i then dedused it was ben and was actually saying to the computer he better fess up soon..

thank you, you're welcome :)

[Xarne]

Hmmm...almost half thought it was Ben...coinciDENCE??? me thinks not

[Phoenix VII]

I was almost certain it was Ben, the only reason I had the slightest doubt was that it was so obvious...almost too obvious.

[Ninnuendo]

Kenny, right from the start. I thought he was manipulating and engineering a situation where we'd be forced to leave the motel.

[SoulShot]

I actually suspected Duck stealing the stuff because of how Kenny acted by stealing stuff from that car, plus he was finding the clues pretty fast. (By the way no Duck on the list) But yeah I should of suspected the more nervous one.

[Milosuperspesh]

agree with xarne, hind sight is an amazing thing...and most people have that at 20/20

to say it after the fact means nothing with out proof..

[IndigoHawk]

Kenny, right from the start. I thought he was manipulating and engineering a situation where we'd be forced to leave the motel.

Good idea. I thought Kenny was just trying to skim supplies for the trip, but trying to force people to leave the motel is a good motive, too.

Ben had opportunity (as the guy on watch) but no clear motive to take the drugs. The line about how the bandit attacks stopped was a clue that someone might have cut a deal, but I had no reason to believe Ben did it instead of anyone else. I don't think there were any clues until Ben reveals his motive.

I also thought maybe someone was injured and stealing drugs for the pain. I remembered Kenny was hurt at the end of episode 2. Maybe someone else was hurt or bit and didn't want to fess up because they knew they'd be killed or thrown out of the compound.

Oh, and I still thought Kenny could have cut the deal right up until the point Ben confessed. I thought Kenny was purposely taking a long time pulling the zombie out from under the RV so that Lilly would take out her rage on someone innocent and Kenny would be cleared. Since Lilly wasn't threatening anyone he cared about, he didn't care what she did.

[FoxxyFox]

As much I loved Carly she gave me at the beginning with her looks & facial expressions the feeling that she perhaps broke the flashlight.

But on the other hand since Lee asked Ben about the chalk/flashlight I thought he is for sure the traitor.

[Deventh]

Ben. I had no real clue, but i knew that it had to be him.

[Hoqt]

I thought it was Kenny because he was shot on episode 2. He probably steal to recover himself.


I didn't play episode 3 yet. Who would need the drugs anyway unless you hurt? The only person got hurt on episode 2 is Kenny.

[Geryk]

not sure............ not sure if it was ben

[xXNinjaScoreXx]

At first I assumed Doug broke the flashlight since he is loves anything with batteries in it, so I though he broke it by accident, but then later I blamed Ben cause...I don't know, I never trusted Ben.

[Fabrimuch]

I had no clue who it could have been right uo until Ben confesses. I remember asking Ben about the flashlight and him being really nervous, but Ben always acts nervous so I didn´t think much of it.

For a bit in the RV I believed Lilly it might have been Carley, but when I remember they would have to write a separate version of the scene for Doug it suddenly made much less sense.

[Walker#8]

I first started leaning toward lily trying to fabricate something to drive a spike between lee and kenny to try to regain some control over the group and power over kenny and lee. Once I started the "investigation" it pretty much came through fairly clearly that it was ben based on his reaction when asked about the flashlight then the chalk "X" on the wall.

[Donut Funn]

I stumbled across the glass before I even questioned anyone, so I had no specific suspicions.

[Caroug]

Ben.

[Sir Fruitcakes]

I thought it was just a accident, and didn't give it another thought, but if I thought it was used in the stealing I would have assumed it was Ben.

[WarDragon989]

Ben.

Lilly was the one who brought it to my attention, and evidence. So It wasn't her.
I trusted Carley. She never seemed the break it and cover up type.
Kenny was with me most times.
Kat is too kind hearted to do something like break and cover up.
Duck or Clem would have admitted it when asked.