Lilly can Return!

[Red Panda]

Kirkman's new book "The Road to Woodbury" contradicts TellTale's version of Lilly.

This means Lilly can make a comeback, if you care. I don't.

I doubt they'll bring her back anyway.

[Snake Liquid]

She could since it's now pretty much confirmed that the Lilly in the game is not the one that appears in the comic. Although, Telltale probably already had the entire story written for this game long ago, and since that included Lilly originally supposed to be the same one from the comic, she's never going to be seen or mentioned again.

Although, by those standards, in my mind Lilly is dead by now. For me, she was left on the side of the road, alone, at night with walkers everywhere with no weapons or supplies. Lilly might be good, but she's not that good. She's a goner.

[RafaelBrasileiro]

if she comes back, TTL have to give us the option to torture her and then kill her.

[Panzer89]

I'm pretty sure the videogame Lily has contradicted comics Lily before.

The one big sticking point is her father

We of course has Larry (http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Larry) in the game.

and we have Everett (http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Everett_Ray_Caul) in the comics.

[rachellouise85]

That's from the book. Lilly is only in a couple of panels in the comic.

[BlankCanvasDJ]

That's from the book. Lilly is only in a couple of panels in the comic.

Yeah but they're some pretty major panels.

[rachellouise85]

You've just spoiled it for peeople who haven't got that far xp.

I'm pretty sure the videogame Lily has contradicted comics Lily before.

By saying that Lilly only appears in a couple of panels, I meant that there was nothing really to contradict. (the father info is from the book) Unless they made her hang around past the time she appears in the comic, not that the game is that long though.^-^

[Viner16]

Death of the Governor :D

[Porr]

Hope not, she was nutty. Having Kenny is enough to deal with.

[Kae]

Actually, the creator said they "ran out of ammo" and it was overrun. He's flat out said that while he won't outright confirm they're dead, he's "done with those characters, they never left the prison", and so that's that.

[rachellouise85]

timeline...at this point the prison thing hasn't occurred.

I don't think she'll be back , they wrote Lilly as comic Lilly (agree with Snake Liquid). Even if they hadn't, I don't think she would find us.

[Ghositex]

She could in fact come back... I don't see this happening, however. I think they just *moved on* with Lilly/Doug/Carley/St johns/Greenes. We are already focusing on Lee and his bite, making Lilly return would just confuse people.

[Kae]

Yeah, it's theoretically possible she could, but I doubt it. Much like Glenn, she's moved on to go assume her role in the comics as we know it.

[DreadMagus]

Actually, the creator said they "ran out of ammo" and it was overrun. He's flat out said that while he won't outright confirm they're dead, he's "done with those characters, they never left the prison", and so that's that.

I don't recall him saying they "never left the prison", I thought he said he was done with the prison and had moved on.

He also stated he's excited to explore her character too (via RTW)

I wouldn't read too much into a quote that neither confirms, nor denies... it's a non-answer.

[QuarterPounderVlad]

Niet.
Even if she does My Lee needs to let loose on someone, Jeez.... I'd torture her and rape her.
:3

[Kae]

Lilly's fate:

The comic does not show her death, but it's revealed that she and the others had run out of ammo. It is currently unknown what becomes of Lilly or any of the other Woodbury residents.

Creator Robert Kirkman wrote: "I'm not going to say (the Woodbury survivors) were all killed (when their bullets ran out), but it's very unlikely that we'll ever see them again. The prison is dead to me. I've moved on and so have the characters."[1][2]

http://walkingdead.wikia.com/wiki/Lilly_Caul_%28Comic_Series%29

Technically, you're correct, but the implication is pretty strong that we won't see Lilly again, because Kirkman is pretty much done with her.

[DreadMagus]

At that time.

Then he wrote RTW - I'm not trying to argue, I'm just suggesting that we shouldn't assume it's set in stone.

[BlankCanvasDJ]

You've just spoiled it for peeople who haven't got that far xp.

Sorry. Figured four and a half years was enough time.

[Phoenix VII]

If Lilly comes back, I'm doing to her what she did to Carley, the group has enough psychological problems to deal with as it is.

Anyway, while the comic Lilly is probably not the same as the game Lilly anymore, Telltale seems to have written her character with the intention of her being the same as the comic version, so while the new novel had changed the game character's status, Telltale probably had finished writing out her story for this season many months ago.

[ZacTB]

I doubt Lily is coming back. Her fate is left ambiguous, and I like to think Video Game Lily is the Lily in the comics and Kirkman already said he is done with the Woodbury Survivors, and anyway Telltale try to explain the way Lily got from Woodbury to Savannah would be awful. Carley/Lily/Doug are definitely not coming back.

[Sergiy]

I'd be glad to see her return.

Also, Lilly gets absolutely no backtory in the comics. All the stuff that contradicts the game is from the novel.

[Comic book spoilers follow]
I can see Lilly making a return. Considering Lori got pregnant during the beginning of the apocalypse and gave birth in approx. 9 months, and we're like 3-4 months in in the game, I feel there is enough time for her to make an appearance.

[FollowLilly]

[Comic book spoilers follow]
I can see Lilly making a return. Considering Lori got pregnant during the beginning of the apocalypse and gave birth in approx. 9 months, and we're like 3-4 months in in the game, I feel there is enough time for her to make an appearance.

exactly what ive been saying, even without the novel, its only been TWO DAYS since she left, her traveling to Woodbury three days later (or even a few months later) would have no bearing on the comics whatsoever unless she died

[TheNNerdGamer]

i doubt Lilly can make a comeback UNLESS
she saw the crew leave
Then again if you take her with you she'll steal the RV

[Basuinny89]

Man I know it's almost impossible but I fell in love With that stubborn bitch !! I'd sure be glad to see her making a comeback one way or another .. Lee and lilly thread should have developed in an intimate way .. Would've been sweet !