A few problems that I've been having with the games...

[Nequam]

1. They're all stuck on low graphics quality, even though they're set to high. I suppose that this doesn't really matter too much, but... It's just weird, is all. Unsettling.

2. The Homestar Ruiner costumes aren't showing up in my other games, although the Strong Badia costumes are showing up in Baddest of the Bands with no problem... o_O? I kinda figured that this easter egg only worked on the Wii version until I got Baddest, or I would have asked before.

Any clues?

[Quuux]

Assuming you are playing the PC versions, you have to be sure not to uninstall the games in between as it removes the registry key responsible.

[Will]

Yeah, if at any time you removed the registry settings for the game, you would have lost the costumes. You could probably check by starting a new Ruiner game and picking up something quick and simple like the hat in the mailbox. Then load up one of the later episodes and see if it shows up.