Telltale Games Forums

Telltale Games Forums (http://www.telltalegames.com/forums/index.php)
-   The Walking Dead Story Discussion - SPOILERS (http://www.telltalegames.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=80)
-   -   My most Unpopular decisions.. (http://www.telltalegames.com/forums/showthread.php?t=37137)

lucid616 10/21/2012 09:17 am

My most Unpopular decisions..
 
Episode 1 - I GAVE Irene the gun - 45 % :(

Episode 2 - Killing Both St. John Bro's - 17 % :)

Episode 3 - I DID NOT shoot Duck - 20 % :eek:

Episode 4 - Letting Ben fall - 37 % :cool:

Episode 5 - ? :confused:

What about you??

Saoralba131 10/21/2012 09:23 am

I had only one of the same unpopular descisions as you,I gave Irene the gun.

Sodawasser 10/21/2012 09:27 am

Episode 1 : gave Irene the gun
Episode 4: didn't kill the attic boy

but I don't know the percentage anymore. It seems like I choose very popular decissions most times..

RafaelBrasileiro 10/21/2012 09:27 am

the opposite of all these.

KingOfTheDead 10/21/2012 09:31 am

i stomped that little boys head. but his face at the end made me laugh

sparkzfly 10/21/2012 09:42 am

I gave Irene the gun and I let Ben fall. Other than that I seem to choose similar decisions as others :)

Kiel555 10/21/2012 10:11 am

Left Dave to die - 15%:eek: Not Lee's finest moment. I tried the trap, then the chain and got in two hits with the axe on his leg before time ran out. Ugh.

Shot Jolene - 12%. All I can say is do not point a loaded weapon at Lee.

Killed both St. John brothers - 17%. :D would do it again in a heart beat too.

Let Ben die - 37%. :D no mercy for traitors!

PeopleSandwich 10/21/2012 10:18 am

Some of you guys gave your group's only firearm, to a mentally unstable woman you just met?

Ignoring the million ways that can go horribly wrong, the absolute best case scenario is that she actually does shoot herself.... When you've just spent 10 minutes trying to creatively kill walkers as quietly as possible so as not to attract more.

This seems like terrible logic and incredibly reckless decision making to me.

Phoenix VII 10/21/2012 10:42 am

Quote:

Originally Posted by PeopleSandwich (Post 704870)
Some of you guys gave your group's only firearm, to a mentally unstable woman you just met?

Ignoring the million ways that can go horribly wrong, the absolute best case scenario is that she actually does shoot herself.... When you've just spent 10 minutes trying to creatively kill walkers as quietly as possible so as not to attract more.

This seems like terrible logic and incredibly reckless decision making to me.

Irene wasn't unstable, she acted like anyone who knows they're going to become a walker would if they don't go into denial, IMO.

Anyway, my less popular decisions were giving the gun to Irene, trying to save Shawn, and apparently siding with Kenny in 1; killing Jolene (she was unstable, aiming a crossbow on me, and threatened to shoot me...I'm not trying my luck with a combination like that), and the brothers in 2; I shot the girl, left Lilly on the road, and talked Kenny down in 3; and in 4 the bells tolled for Ben.

FarmerJoe 10/21/2012 10:54 am

I wonder if anyone can beat my low scores...

Episode 1 - 23% C'mon,Doug deserves to live too!

Episode 2 - 15% Teacher left behind, I like to evaluate all the options first, sorry Dave...

Episode 3 - 11% Chose to leave with Lilly.Taking Clem and leaving with a friend and a fellow murderer, hoping for a fresh start for the three of them, seemed more appealing than staying with the ongoing misery of a dying child,a idiotic traitor and a redneck who hated Lee...
sorry Katjaa.

Episode 4 - 8% Finally telling a guy who left my Lee to die TWICE, and who valued his grudge more than an innocent small girl's life, to go Fuck himself!
Petty-yes but also very satisfying.

MesterF 10/21/2012 11:32 am

I tried to save shawn, gave Irene the gun, left Lilly on the side of the road and did let Kenny kill the boy in the house. I think that was all

DarcKage 10/21/2012 11:33 am

I shot Jolene.

...which I kind of regret, since my main game's a 'nice Lee' file.

Dragash1 10/21/2012 11:42 am

Only one i remember is that i didnt took the food out of the car. Most people did take it... i can understand it though.

lucid616 10/21/2012 12:10 pm

I only regret and may rewind to tell Kenny to fuck himself, I said I NEEDED him incase he could help or maybe change his mind, or grow a spine. And I didnt want him to get pissed and leave with the boat, which kind of worked , I guess, but still fuck Kenny.

Viser 10/21/2012 12:35 pm

On Episode 1 - I left at night, told Kenny we'd kick Larry's ass, Gave Irene the gun, and saved Doug.

Episode 2 - Not taking the food is the only thing here.

Episode 3 - Helped Omid first, Talked Kenny down.

Episode 4 - I got Kenny to kill the kid in the attic, and didn't bring Clementine to Crawford.

DreadMagus 10/21/2012 06:49 pm

E1 - Gave Irene the gun (45%) - Saved Duck (49%) - Sided with Kenny (48%)
E2 - none, apparently.
E3 - Abandoned Lilly (41%)
E4 - Killed Mini-Zed (20%) <--- WTF - why on earth would you leave a walker alive in a house you're in....

Rock114 10/21/2012 07:44 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by DreadMagus (Post 705254)
E1 - Gave Irene the gun (45%) - Saved Duck (49%) - Sided with Kenny (48%)
E2 - none, apparently.
E3 - Abandoned Lilly (41%)
E4 - Killed Mini-Zed (20%) <--- WTF - why on earth would you leave a walker alive in a house you're in....

Actually Dread, everyone else let Kenny kill the walker. While walking away IS an option, virtually everyone has either killed the kid themselves, or let Kenny do it.

E1: Gave Irene the gun
E2: Shot Jolene, didn't steal the food. Wish I had done the opposite of those two things.
E3: Didn't help Omid. I probably would have if the camera hadn't settled on Christa, because his shirt reminds me of Fallout: New Vegas.
E4: Didn't take Clem to Crawford, dropped Ben.

Red Panda 10/21/2012 09:15 pm

In ep 3. I chose to go with Lilly when she offered in the RV my first playthrough. They mentioned on a Playing Dead episode that the stat was like 6%. haha I was tired of the group at that point.

DreadMagus 10/21/2012 10:39 pm

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rock114 (Post 705297)
Actually Dread, everyone else let Kenny kill the walker. While walking away IS an option, virtually everyone has either killed the kid themselves, or let Kenny do it.

E1: Gave Irene the gun
E2: Shot Jolene, didn't steal the food. Wish I had done the opposite of those two things.
E3: Didn't help Omid. I probably would have if the camera hadn't settled on Christa, because his shirt reminds me of Fallout: New Vegas.
E4: Didn't take Clem to Crawford, dropped Ben.

Well, Kenny was boohooing about it - so I didn't think he'd have the balls.

Besides, if I made him do it, I figured he'd NEVER LET ME FORGET....

WHAT HAVE YOU DONE FOR ME EXCEPT MAKE ME KILL A ZOMBIE KID, LEE?!?!?! Y U NO DO FOR ME!!!!!!!!

That1Guy 10/22/2012 05:05 am

Ep1-Gave Irene the gun.
Ep2-Didn't take the food.
Ep3-Left Lilly behind.
Ep4-Killed the boy.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 03:50 am.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2013, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.