Who kidnapped clementine?
 

I'm confused with the story. In the end of episode 4 Clementine gets kidnapped by some mysterious person but what does he want with clem? I think it is the father of the boy in the attic but what are your suggestions?

There are many secrets along episode four, I think.
What is Molly's secret agenda? (If there is one and I think there is.)
Why did Vernon wanted Lee to give Clem himself?
Was it all planned to force them to get into the manor by ringing the church bell?
Why did noone ever know that Crawford was long f.cked up?
For what did Molly exactly left the group for?
Why does the kidnapper want Clem so badly? Is it about her parents?

And was Clem really necessary meant to be that stupid.

I don't know any of them but I'm with you there.
I think he is EXACTLY father of the boy in the attic who kidnapped Clem if he is EXACTLY the same person who stalked Lee while he was burying the kid.

This really is the biggest mystery of the game. Who's on the other end of the walkie talkie? I've been theorizing all month and nothing feels right, can't wait to see who it is.

Father of the boy in the attic would mean the biggest coincidence ever, of our group choosing the walkie talkie man's house as shelter. That would be a bigger coincidence than everybody holding up in Lee's family's drug store in episode 1.

He wants........ A kid. My guess. He wants to have a kid.

Joelenes husband lmao

He's just using Clem as a means to get what he wants from the group. My guess is that he wants the boat, and he will only trade Clem for it.

Couldn't be that anyway, the man wanted Clem in episode 3 as well when he learned that you were coming to Savannah.

I wonder how he knows who we are though, since he says Lee on the walkie talkie in episode 3 he knows you're coming there in episode 3 and who clem. is.

Too many questions.

I really have no idea. But i thinks he wants something from the group. It could be the boat, but he already contacted Clem before the group even found a boat. It seems weird to stalk a group of people in the hope they find something he could use.

How did he know about the boat? There was no guarantee that they'd even find a boat when Clem first started talking to the man. So I'm not sure why he'd want to use her as a bargaining chip when there may not have even been a boat to gain.

the owner of the car from EP 2 is my guess.

He's just some dude that wants to give her..... candy.

I don't think its Chuck... :)

Do we think he was always in Savannah, or was he always shadowing the group?

I think he's always been in Savannah, I mean theres no way he could have been following the group when they were on the train and the first thing he says is "Cant wait for you to get to Savannah, Clementine".

He warned the group to get out the streets because he seen them coming in episode 4. So the question is he not totally stalking the group he wants something maybe he the brother of the Senator Lee killed something deep like that and it just happen chance, luck, he came across Clem via walkie talkie!!!!

Lets break it down to the first question we should be answering. Was it the man who watched you dig the boy in the attic that made us jump?

What if he and Molly are in cahoots. Dun Dun duun. Married and then its round 2 Molly.

I think the guy on the radio (sicko1) and the creepy guy (sicko2) at the fence are two different groups. Sicko1 is in an elevated position like in the penthouse of a high rise building since he's able to see movement below like Lee's group and the walkers. He has no reason to get a closer look at the backyard of the house he saw Lee's group run into. Sicko2 heard all the gun fire, commotion and attempted break in of the house and came to investigate. He ran away since he thought Lee's group was most likely from Crawford just like Molly concluded.

Whoever it is, they must be really capable to have survived in Savannah so long, especially if they have been surviving alone. If he's part of a group then surely Molly or Vernon would have known about them? I wonder if it's a Crawford survivor.

I'm starting to wonder who the guy watching Lee bury the boy was. He didn't look or act how I would expect the guy on the walkie talkie to act. Maybe that was the father of the boy? He couldn't tear himself away from seeing his son finally buried. He'll feel indebted to Lee for releasing him from his misery!

I chuckled