Arrrrr... It's the epic Monkey Island™ "Did You Try" list, matey!
 

Do you know what is so epic about this list, it's because it's not about one of Monkey Island™ games, but all of them, including the new one TMI™. The few ones I remember are only from Curse of Monkey Island™

So in Curse of Monkey Island™ did you try...
giving the arm back to Murray
using the ventroliquisim book with every one you meet
giving some gum to Murray
putting the pin on the vodoo doll again
using the burning piece of wood with the vodoo doll

I liked giving the arm with glue on it to Murray. Then try it again. his response is hilarious.
you can also use the arm on the voodoo doll.

In Secret of Monkey Island did you
Stay underwater for 10 minutes?

In CoMI did you
Insist that Guybrush go into the sea on Blood Island?

Did you in CoMI go visit murray when tarred and feathered
in SoMI die in the acid pool

In SoMI did you:
Use the catapult on the pirate ship?

In CoMI did you:

Use the cannon on the fort multiple times?
Look at and use golden Elaine multiple times?
Take all the tarot cards from the medium and ask her for all the readings?
Do the "lighting the stage" puzzle in Mega Monkey mode?
Ask the smugglers for a toy?
Use the toy multiple times and listen to all of it's responses?
Use the elevator without using the umbrella?
Look at the button on the skeleton in Blondebeard's?
Use the ventriloquism book with the skeleton in Blondebeard's?
Look at and use all the items in Captain LeChimp's cabin?
Find all the porcelain and interact with it?
Look at Wally in Big Whoop?
Keep hitting Dinghy Dog in Big Whoop?
Try to talk to Murray after getting the anchor?

I love the topic's name!

In CMI, did you try:
Licking the alligator tongue?

If you actually managed to do that in SoMi, it will be a feat for the ages! :p

Seriously, you mean MI2, right?

And to add one from EMI:

Did you get every possible prosthetic and assemble them into an unholy thing?

Thank you!

Just look at all the "Secrets" sections here. Topic over. :p

Nope! It doesn't tell all the responses, use one item with a cetain object or character!

Here I have a few. In Secret of Monkey Island, did you
escape the cannibals' guest hut multiple times and look at the door multiple times?
go as far to the right as possible on the highest point on Monkey Island?
free the rat from the cell?
bought a ship for 4000 pieces of eight?
free the rat from the cell?
learned an insult before taking sword lessons?
found four different ways to blast the dam?
bought the sword before talking to the important looking pirates?
try to turn off the grog machine? (only available in floppy versions)

From Monkey Island 2

Find out what colour the tree is from Herman Toothrot

Examine the Keep Left sign in the shop on Booty Island

That one is not on the secrets page, but I remember that this happened to me when I was playing MI in the 90ies.

I don't remember exactly where it was, but...
In one of the two first games you could fall from a cliff and die. No, not really die. You saw a picture of the falling Guybrush for a moment and were asked if you want to load a game, restart or quit. A split second later Guybrush was catapulted back. He said something about a rubber tree down there. When I replayed the games a few days ago I couldn't find it any more. It's either in SoMI when you get Herman's paddles or in LCR at the cliff where the map is.

It's what happens when you;)
In case you were searching for it in the Sega-CD version, it's broken there.

Guess it's that. No, I wasn't searching in the SEGA-version, what I own is the CD-ROM version. Maybe it's just in the 3,5" version?

I literally just tried it and it works on my CD-ROM version. (I'd never known it before though, so thanks for posting it!)

Just to make sure we're doing the same thing:
You go up to the top of the cliff on SMI, while you're on Monkey Island. Once you're at the top (where the pile of rocks are and everything) just walk to the right. The screen should scroll. Eventually the ground beneath Guybrush will break and he'll fall down. A "you have to load/restart" message then comes up, but then Guybrush comes back and says, "rubber tree!"

Yep, just tried. Thanx. I just had been at the wrong place. Nice joke, isn't it?
The was a rubber tree in CoMI... guess that was one of these special jokes.