Try clicking on the toaster or the bread bin.
Oh dear, the neighbourhood squirrel appears to have run off with your toast! He also grabbed a teabag.
Hmm, he keeps doing it. Notice how he steps on the breadboard before stealing the toast? Maybe we need to make it slippery
And the real solution:
Take the butter from the fridge, place it on the breadboard, and click the toaster/breadbox again. The squirrel will slip up and you can successfully keep the toast.