I think everyones very supportive of telltale and what they've done.. Its just that sam and max is important to a lot of people and they just wanna see this new game done right.. If there wasnt the current discussions goin on I'd be worried because it would probably be a sign of lack of interest in the new game.. The fact that every single frame of the trailer is being analysed just proves how rabbid the fans are
Amen to that. Experienced gamers as a rule are fussy and can get quite heated when it comes to a franchise they are a big fan of. I myself have made posts of critique both in favour and against certain aspects of the trailer.
The animation looks great and the premise is sound. The voices as ive remarked are pretty good likeness wise to not just past appearances but to how I would IMAGINE Sam and Max to sound. They just need some minor tweaks and a bit of work on comedy timing and delivery.
The fact that these boards ARE showing so much activity shows just HOW much interest there is.
Most old gamers I know agree that Hit the Road was one of if not THE best old school adventure game ever made and are champing at the bit for Sam & Max's triumphant return.
My point is when you are this excited about a game there is always this horrible gnawing worry that it wont be anywhere near as good as you had hoped. This isnt because we doubt Telltale's ability, it's just a natural feeling people get.
To sum up, Telltale for simply CONSIDERING the Sam & Max franchise and for coming so far with it I love you all.