Originally Posted by nitsujsedohr
I got a few laughs out of the parrot, but I think we should leave it be. I did get pretty annoyed with it near the end. I think they should've kept it melted and lost in the sea. They could've brought it back during season 2 for a good joke
While I agree that the joke gets old pretty quickly, I can think of a large number of situations in a courtroom where "It's me, Guybrush Threepwood, mighty pirate" could be amusing/awkward/unlucky.
So we'll probably see it return in this episode.