You guys are forgeting one single element of this puzzle. You guys didn't mention about this one in your posts, so I'm putting this as a reminder. If you already know this, I'm really sorry for being such a wiseass.
The thing is, where LeChuck jumps from is also an important aspect of this puzzle.
You have to go to the wheelhouse after LeChuck launches you to the crow's nest. Then wait for LeChuck, and then talk to Elaine and click on the seesaw only once. It doesn't work if LeChuck jumps from crow's nest to main sail. LeChuck HAS to jump down from wheelhouse in order to land on the seesaw perfectly.
Last edited by Falanca; 12/30/2009 at 12:31 pm.