Originally Posted by GuruGuru214
I really don't have any ideas, but I can say that I'm against the idea of re-using "Tales" in the title. There's so many other options possible under the "____ of Monkey Island" paradigm, to see a second game called "Tales" again would feel a bit stale to me. Random ideas off the top of my head: (The) Legend(s) of Monkey Island, Journey to Monkey Island, The Fortress of Monkey Island.
I say it should be Tales 2, if that game will turn out to use the same graphics and engine and all. After all, all games in the franchise differ greatly from each other.