Originally Posted by tobar
This thread isn't what I thought it was going to be about. Here's what happened to me, somehow I gained access to SammunMak without getting a third badge! I dunno how that happend all I did was trick Grandpa Stinky and give Max as a toaster to Sal. Then all of a sudden Sam exclaimed that we had all three badges and was excited to see the Pharoah. Even though I never won that last badge in a bet. I still don't know how to solve that one and I've already beat the game!
It IS probably about that problem you've encountered.
Accusing Grandpa Stinky a heretic for a second time tricks the game into believing that you got a SECOND badge, althought what you've done is simply doing the same thing to get your first badge. It's a bug of the game.
I feel sorry for your experience, also. The puzzle behind the other badge was also a good one.