Ok, here's a list of voices I need so far:
Elaine
The Voodoo Lady Lechuck
Chuckie
Guybrush as a child
Elaine as a child
old man Guybrush
John Decringe (a reference to Joseph Decreaux and Desinge)
Winslow
SilverWolfPet is now cast as Stan (yay

)
I'm also wanting to try and work Largo in, but we'll see.
Anyways, what I have so far is that it will be set between Monkey Island 2 and Curse, not making my own "Monkey Island 3" or anything but just a "what if?" that you do not under any circumstances have to follow as canon (duh, it's a fan game!) but if you want to that's also fine
The main focus will be going through the carnival trying to escape but you will also be able to go to secret locations on Monkey Island that haven't been seen ever before, just so I don't have to rely on using old backgrounds.
This brings me to my next point. I need background artists.