Opinions. Opinions everywhere.
I kinda get the point your making. If someone asked me why do I like the BTTF game, my answer would be because it's Telltale! At first that might sound like me being a fangirl, but it's not. I just like all of what Telltale has done with their games.
If Telltale went into a different direction would I be pissed? Sure. A little. But there's probably more of those out there who would prefer a change then those who would not. Who am I to say which direction a gaming company goes in?