Hello. I'm back again. Here's the next trophy guide.
She's Cute When She's Angry: Got Morgan angry by repeatedly checking out the mast.
This is easy! When you first battle Morgan, select the mainmast of the Screaming Narwhal and click on it at least four-five times until she gets angry, stops complaining, and grumbles incoherently.
Meals Fit for a King... Queen... Whatever: Gave the MerLeader every kind of bait.
There are three bait coupons found throughout the game as follows:
Glowy Bait, referred to as the "Gusanos de destino": Found in the 101 Fish Jokes book after you ask Tetra for it (see also "Silver: Model of E-FISH-Ency").
Fish Eggs: Found on the Fishing Well in Spoon Isle (see also "Bronze: Fishing for Literalists").
Oyster: Found on the cliff near where the clamshell and LeChuck are.
Show all these coupons to Anemone at the Bait and Repair Shop in Spinner Cay and you'll get all three kinds of bait to show to the MerLeader (make sure you show the oyster to him/her BEFORE examining it for a pearl!).
Fishing for Literalists: Caught a Red Herring.
Also easy! After getting the Fish Eggs, as described in the aforementioned bronze trophy, return to the Fishing Well on Spoon Isle and combine the hook with the fish eggs to nab a (literal!) red herring.
Talk to the Hook: Threatened a number of adversaries with a Hook.
At the very beginning, as soon as you use the hook on the cable in the Narwhal, use said hook on Morgan after Guybrush uses it to replace his lost hand. Later on, after leaving a besieged Spinner Cay, sail to the blockade BEFORE moving on to Spoon Isle, and use the hook to threaten Killick Hardtack. After moving to Spoon Isle and confronting LeChuck and the pox-ridden pirates, use the hook on the latter guys. Finally, after clearing the blockade, confront Captain McGillicutty and use the hook on him.
Nice Try: Heard the Secret of Donkey Island.
After rescuing Chieftain Beluga and returning to Spinner Cay, as soon as the conversation topics come up, ask him/her what the Secret of Monkey Island is BEFORE selecting "I need to find La Esponja Grande."
Give Her a Hand: Kicked LeFlay off the Screaming Narwhal.
Easy! Once you've managed to get Morgan off the Narwhal, the first silver trophy of this chapter is yours.
Model of E-FISH-Ency: Read every fish joke.
After asking Tetra for the 101 Fish Jokes book and getting a coupon for the Glowy Bait (as described in "Bronze: Meals Fit for a King... Queen... Whatever"), examine said book at least 14 times for this trophy.
Ride 'Em, Pirate: Made LeChuck do something embarrassing on the cliff.
The first time you find LeChuck on the cliff in Spoon Isle, speak with him and ask him, "So, how much longer do you think?", then, "What are you carrying with you?", and finally, "Use..." "...claw thingie..." "...yourself."
Artifacts of Life: Got all the Summoning Artifacts.
Easy, again! Once you've found all the Summoning Artifacts and returned to Spinner Cay, the trophy will unlock.
Mighty Merperson Rescuer: Saved the MerLeader from McGillicutty.
Once you've got the rubber tree from Brillig Island and asked Anemone to make a mast out of it for the Screaming Narwhal on Spinner Cay's Bait and Repair Shop, return to McGillicutty's ship and insult him for the final silver trophy.
The BIG Finish: Sailed to the alleged resting place of La Esponja Grande.
Use the Summoning Ball Artifact and select an answer when Winslow asks you if you're ready. At the last cutscene of this chapter, select all answers when confronted by Morgan to nab the second gold trophy and end the chapter.
I'll do another guide for Chapter 3 later.