View Single Post
Old 07/19/2011, 11:10 pm   #56
WareKurt
Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2010
Posts: 74
Default

Quote:
in 1955 marty showed up twice on the same day. The second time doc was there with him but he didn't have to be.
In 1931 we also see an instance of 2 marty's at the court house in episode 2.
But as far as I know they are the same Martys, not from 2 different original timelines. Their ages are slightly different but both of them supposed to remember TP timeline.

Quote:
So at this point if marty were to revisit either november 12th 1955 or june 13th 1931 we'd have the same result; 3 marty's from 3 different timelines.
I don't think so, the Marty on the stage has to be TP, the one travelling also is TP and the Marty in the game is supposed to be the TP Marty we known from the movies. Without someone else directing an alternate one, the alternates cannot decide to travel some time different.

Think about this, TP Marty travels and alters past so TPMall becomes LPMall. And we have a LP Marty up to the point TP travelled, he has known the mall as LPMall all along. So without someone interfering and telling him what had happened, can LP Marty make a trip on his own? Can the events be changed only by the actions of the alternates? I believe alternates has to follow prior one's actions. So for example without anyone telling him, LP Marty can not decide to put plutonium case in the car while recording. Or without anyone telling him, he can not change the time on the circuits to a closer time where it wouldn't be much trouble for past Doc to repair them. For alternates to be meeting like this, there has to be someone who directed them.
WareKurt is offline   Reply With Quote