Originally Posted by LadyJ
Oh I was also surprised by how many the stats said left Lilly on the side of the road. I understand why but I brought her with me. I'm not real fond of the whole bonding buddy thing which has probably been realized, so I didn't really mind her personality that much. What she did was absolutely crazy and wrong. BUT she was a good shot. The group needed that skill. Of course she wound up leaving anyway but I was being pragmatic about the event.
I think that moment was influenced more by player rage than logical thought. Given the huge number of Carley fans (including myself), to see your favourite character coldly shot then I can't blame the choice people made.