Originally Posted by YamiRaziel
What's so difficult to understand? I shot the girl because I still have some humanity left. Kenny wouldn't, but I'm sure that he will pull a Shane on me if his life depends on that.
If you shoot the girl, Kenny will proudly confess to the group. There's a difference between doing what's necessary and bragging about it. Kenny is an idiot. Even his wife doesn't agree with him.
So. What if you shoot the girl, attract the walkers and you both die in the drug store? The supplies never make it back to the group and that's that.
You put a stranger out of her misery sure, but you are now dead. The rest of the group is probably dead as well. And I don't want to hear "oh.. well that didn't happen", because at the time it's a damn good possibility that it could happen.
There was nothing MONSTROUS about what Kenny suggested at all. It was a good suggestion for the good of the group, and our group is more important than a stranger who is dead anyway.