Originally Posted by YamiRaziel
She's not a monster and she wouldn't have killed him. They would've banished him from the group. That's it!
Carley died because she started talking back in the worst possible moment. Had she said it wasn't her and that it must have been Ben, he would crack and admit it was him.
Defending the guy who almost got the entire group killed isn't something to be proud of. She was obstructing the law! (Lee)
As much as I like Lily; somebody was definitely dying that night
Im sure she was seeing Red the minute they had to leave the motel and in the way they had to do it.