I don't vote since I haven't read the comics or the novels and the Activision game hasn't released. Anyway I am pretty sure that I wouldn't like the comics because I hate reading comics (uuh, 100 of pictures with 6 words, how exciting..) but what's the problem with the Activision game? Why you all hate it? I thought there isn't a gameplay trailer until yet and the description sounds like a Deus Ex in the Walking Dead universe which would be quite cool..
About the characters (at least I have read the comic plots): In my opinion this is the positive argument about the comics. I mean the thing, that everyone is a dick. That is the realistic thing which would happen with people in such situations.