Originally Posted by CarScar
Scenario I thought of:
Carley: "You think you're some tough bitch, don't you? Like nothing can hurt you. But, you're just a scared little girl. Get the fuck over it. Take a page from Lee's book and try helping somebody for once."
*Kenny deals with the walker, Lilly takes a few steps back*
Kenny: "Now, what's the fuck the prob-"
Lilly: "Everyone, back the fuck off!!"
*Lilly has her gun drawn, pointing towards the group*
Lilly: "Now I know one of you (Carley or Ben) betrayed us! We can't let someone who endangers our group left alive! Now, Lee tell me! Who did it!!"
There you are given the option to chose who you think did it. You can either say it was Ben or Carley. Depending on your relationship with Lilly you can say it was yourself: if she likes you she'll say there was no way it was you, if she doesn't like you she'll shoot you in the chest. You'll live the shot but you'll need immediate help and nearly die. You may also try to talk her down: if she likes you you can make her stop, if she doesn't like you she wont stop.
My choice would be to take the blame on supplies being stolen. Since I helped Kenny, she'll shoot me. It's a big risk, but if means that no one else ends up dying, well then, that's the way it goes.