I didn't figure it out until we got to the farm. Everyone was being creepy and they kept bringing up dinner like "Yeah, supper's gonna be REAAAALLLL good >
So I turned to my friend and I said as a joke "CANNIBALS!" and we were having a laugh about it.
Then we opened the door at the back of the barn. And umm... yeah. We knew from then on.
My reaction: "Oh my God, you're really eating people, aren't you? Oh, jeez, the group is in your house! *runs up to the house to save them*"
My friend's reaction: "ARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGG GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGHHHHHHHH!"
So, yeah. I didn't twig that they were eating Mark until I walked in and Brenda said "Mark won't be down for dinner, you can't see him, he's resting". So obviously I ran straight upstairs and saw he wasn't in the bed, turned on the lights and found the secret room...
I didn't think Mark would be in there :L I thought they'd have eaten Mark. Like, fully eaten Mark. So there'd be nothing left. So I walked in, expecting to have to examine the place for clues or puddles of blood or more morphine or something... only to be confronted by a legless Mark warning me not to eat dinner.
And the first thing I notice is not his lack of legs, his bloodiness, or the fact that he's lying half-dead on the bathroom floor.
Nope. The first thing my mind registers; "Hey, where'd his glasses go?"