[Scaeva]

I knew something was suspiscious about the St. John brothers from the moment they first showed up looking for gas, but did not guess cannibalism immediately. I had Lee vote for not going with them.

I knew something bad was going to happen however, both because their offer seemed too good to be true, and because finding a farm that was a little slice of paradise where the group had all the food they could possibly need, and were protected from walkers, would make for boring drama.

That being said, I did guess cannibalism before Lee does in the game. The combo of Jolene's comments, Danny's suspiscious behavior and Brenda making excuses that prevented you from seeing Mark telegraphed that they were cannibals. Also the St. John brothers use the excuse that they heard Mark yell as the reason they turned on the electric fence, when no one yelled until after it had been turned on.